Snorkel-reviewed task review-a77f124e37f3ac9b
contested/defectiveOutside aggregate scope- Reference solution (oracle)
- Pass
- No-op resistance check
- Pass
- QA verdict
- snorkel review: needs-revision x2
- Aggregate eligibility
- Excluded / other version
- Known task defect recorded
These per-version observations remain visible, but this version does not contribute to aggregate pass rates.
The task
Excerpt only; not a complete executable task specification. Task ID review-a77f124e37f3ac9b · version 1. Selection status: not fully recorded.
Results by model and effort
This exact task version only. Every rate is passes / valid runs with a Wilson 95% interval; n≤2 remains counts only. Macro aggregation does not apply within a single task. Baselines are summarized in the quality gates, not ranked. A passed no-op resistance check means that doing nothing did not solve the task.
Current evidence
| Model / effort | Verifier result [95% Wilson] | Diagnostic labels / valid | HARNESS_ERROR · excluded | Outcome classes |
|---|
Legacy evidence
| Model / effort | Verifier result [95% Wilson] | Diagnostic labels / valid | HARNESS_ERROR · excluded | Outcome classes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Opus 4.8 · default (unverified) | 0/1 | 0 / 1 | 4 | GOOD_FAILURE: 0 BAD_FAILURE: 0 GOOD_SUCCESS: 0 BAD_SUCCESS: 0 |
| GPT-5.5 · default (unverified) | 3/5 · 60.0% [23.1%, 88.2%] | 0 / 5 | 0 | GOOD_FAILURE: 0 BAD_FAILURE: 0 GOOD_SUCCESS: 0 BAD_SUCCESS: 0 |
Every recorded run
14 recorded trials, including controls. Diagnostic labels do not replace verifier reward. Labels and quality checks are source declarations, not independently attested here. Internal evidence remains private; a missing public URL is shown explicitly. Records with invalid or absent rewards are not scored.
| Run / model | Date / source | Reward / eligibility | Diagnostic class / source | Resources | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
tbench-task__8LKxbnkoracle@@ | Not recorded repo | 1 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: — Turns: — Cost: — | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__J9Ga5aYnop@@ | Not recorded repo | 0 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: — Turns: — Cost: — | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__wxCVN8moracle@@ | Not recorded repo | 1 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: — Turns: — Cost: — | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__DkLCwV9oracle@@ | Not recorded repo | 1 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: — Turns: — Cost: — | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__a3L97ABClaude Opus 4.8 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 0 · excludedharness_error | HARNESS_ERROR derived | Tokens: 40,175 Turns: — Cost: $2.4650 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__MapWqsvClaude Opus 4.8 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 0 · excludedharness_error | HARNESS_ERROR derived | Tokens: 28,000 Turns: — Cost: $1.6519 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__8mi8yoMGPT-5.5 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 1 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: 26,287 Turns: — Cost: $3.2949 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__8kKd5dPGPT-5.5 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 1 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: 19,345 Turns: — Cost: $1.7419 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__ihhsjHYGPT-5.5 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 1 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: 40,596 Turns: — Cost: $4.2989 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__W5qjurSClaude Opus 4.8 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 0 · excludedharness_error | HARNESS_ERROR derived | Tokens: 33,947 Turns: — Cost: $2.4098 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__SrGx8hQGPT-5.5 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 0 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: 35,117 Turns: — Cost: $4.3096 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__vamtg52Claude Opus 4.8 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 0 · excludedharness_error | HARNESS_ERROR derived | Tokens: 42,363 Turns: — Cost: $2.2718 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__2LDuQJEGPT-5.5 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 0 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: 25,379 Turns: — Cost: $2.7052 | Not publicly available |
tbench-task__pmmYuzUClaude Opus 4.8 · default (unverified) | Not recorded repo | 0 · valid | No diagnostic label derived | Tokens: 18,583 Turns: — Cost: $1.1465 | Not publicly available |