SyncValsverifier → artifact → classifier → verdict
SyncVals · Trajectory

session-token-verify

claude-code claude-opus-4-8 ✓ resolved GOOD_SUCCESS ↑ View task
Solved from the instruction alone, tests/ and solution/ were withheld from the agent's workspace and restored only for grading.
Reward = tests/test.sh exit code (0 → resolved); the classification below is post-hoc and cannot change it.
Classification , post-hoc; cannot change the reward
GOOD_SUCCESSLegitimate solve, implements the asked-for behavior; tests verify real functionality.
SubtypeLegitimate Solution
EvidenceTest output: 'Test Files 2 passed (2), Tests 50 passed (50)' with all named tests passing: 'deviation: audience prefix match', 'deviation: effective scopes', 'malformed structure and missing claims', 'failure precedence', and 'differential fuzz vs independent oracle' tests. Agent implementation correctly handles: (1) token structure parsing with 3 base64url segments; (2) header validation (alg='HS256' check, kid lookup); (3) signature via canonical string (sorted keys, JSON.stringify values, &-joined); (4) time bounds (ctx.now <= iat+exp for lifetime, ctx.now >= nbf-30 for not-before); (5) audience prefix matching (case-sensitive); (6) scope intersection when both scope/scopes present, single when one present, empty when neither; (7) version check (ver !== 0 and ver >= minVer); (8) strict failure precedence order (malformed > bad_signature > expired > not_yet_valid > wrong_audience > revoked > insufficient_scope).
Root causeThe agent successfully implemented the STV/1 token verifier by correctly understanding and implementing all specification rules, passing all 50 behavioral and fuzz tests without modification to restricted files (crypto, types, errors, tests).
RecommendationN/A - task is fine
Trajectory
Tool-by-tool agent trajectory
10 tool calls · 3 tool types · 13 steps
Agent session started, model: claude-opus-4-8 · 30 tools available · cwd: /home/user/app

/home/user/instruction.md

contents
1	# Ticket: Implement `verify` for STV/1 session tokens
2	
3	## Context
4	
5	`session-token-verify` is the library every backend service uses to authenticate
6	incoming callers. Clients present an **STV/1** bearer token; a service hands the
7	token plus a verification context to this library and gets back either the
8	authenticated subject (with its effective scopes) or a reason the token was
9	rejected (TypeScript, Node 20).
10	
11	The crypto and encoding primitives (HMAC-SHA256, base64url, constant-time
12	compare), the typed `AuthError`, and all the request/response types are already
13	in place. **Only the verifier itself , `verify` , is unimplemented**, so no
14	service can authenticate anyone yet.
15	
16	## Your task
17	
18	Implement the function in:
19	
20	    src/auth/verify.ts   ->   verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult
21	
22	The full contract is written as JSDoc directly above the stub in that file , it
23	is the spec; the summary below repeats it.
24	
25	## The contract
26	
27	### Token shape
28	
29	An STV/1 token is three base64url segments joined by dots: `header.payload.sig`.
30	`header` decodes to JSON `{ alg, kid }`. `payload` decodes to a JSON object of
31	claims; the claim names are `sub`, `iat`, `exp`, `nbf`, `aud`, `scope`,
32	`scopes`, and `ver`, and a payload may also carry other claims.
33	
34	### Algorithm
35	
36	`alg` must equal `"HS256"`; any other value is not accepted.
37	
38	### Signature
39	
40	Let `secret = ctx.keys[kid]`. Form the **canonical** string from the payload:
41	take every key present in the payload object, sort the keys in ascending
42	(code-unit) order, render each key as `key=value` where `value` is the
43	`JSON.stringify` of that claim's value, and join the pairs with `&`. For example
44	a payload `{ sub: "u1", iat: 1000, exp: 3600, aud: ["a"] }` has canonical string
45	
46	    aud=["a"]&exp=3600&iat=1000&sub="u1"
47	
48	The expected signature is `base64url(HMAC-SHA256(secret, canonical))` and must
49	equal the token's `sig` segment.
50	
51	### Time
52	
53	`iat` and `exp` are seconds. The token is within its lifetime iff
54	`ctx.now <= iat + exp`. `nbf` is absolute epoch seconds; the token has reached
55	its start iff `ctx.now >= nbf - SKEW`, where `SKEW` is `30`. The lifetime bound
56	takes no leeway.
57	
58	### Audience
59	
60	`aud` is an array of strings. `ctx.audience` is accepted iff some entry of `aud`
61	is a prefix of `ctx.audience`, compared case-sensitively (an entry equal to
62	`ctx.audience` counts as a prefix of it).
63	
64	### Scopes
65	
66	The effective scopes are the intersection of `scope` (split on single spaces,
67	discarding empty tokens) and `scopes` when both claims are present; whichever one is present when only one is;
68	and the empty set when neither is. A claim counts as present whenever its key
69	exists (an empty or whitespace-only value is present but contributes no tokens, so
70	e.g. an empty `scope` alongside a `scopes` array yields the empty intersection).
71	The effective scopes are de-duplicated. When `ctx.requiredScopes` is present and
72	non-empty, every entry in it must appear in the effective scopes.
73	
74	### Version
75	
76	`ver` must be present and satisfy `ver >= ctx.minVer`. A `ver` of `0` is never
77	accepted.
78	
79	### Result and reason precedence
80	
81	On success return `{ valid: true, sub, scopes }`, where `scopes` is the effective
82	scope set. On rejection return `{ valid: false, reason }`. A token may break more
83	than one rule; return the first reason that applies in this order:
84	
85	    malformed > bad_signature > expired > not_yet_valid > wrong_audience >
86	    revoked > insufficient_scope
87	
88	`malformed` covers a token whose structure cannot be read or whose required
89	claims are absent: not exactly three segments, a segment that is not valid
90	base64url, a header or payload that is not JSON of the expected shape, an `alg`
91	other than `"HS256"`, a `kid` with no entry in `ctx.keys`, or a missing `sub`,
92	`iat`, `exp`, `nbf`, `aud`, or `ver`. `expired` is the lifetime bound failing;
93	`not_yet_valid` is the start bound failing; `wrong_audience` is the audience rule
94	failing; `revoked` is the version rule failing; `insufficient_scope` is a
95	required scope absent from the effective set.
96	
97	## Definition of done
98	
99	- `npm run typecheck` is clean.
100	- `npm test` passes the full suite in `test/` , the behavioural tests plus a
101	  differential fuzz suite that checks the verifier against an independent model.
102	- Implement the feature within `verify` (and any private helpers you add in
103	  `src/auth/`). Do not modify the provided crypto, types, or errors modules, or
104	  the test files.
105	
106	## Running locally
107	
108	```bash
109	npm install      # already done in the provided environment
110	npm run typecheck
111	npm test
112	```
113

/home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts

contents
1	import { hmacSha256, base64urlDecode, base64urlEncode, timingSafeEqual } from "./crypto.js";
2	import type { VerifyContext, VerifyResult } from "./types.js";
3	
4	/**
5	 * Verify an STV/1 session token.
6	 *
7	 * A token is three base64url segments joined by dots: `header.payload.sig`.
8	 * `header` decodes to JSON `{ alg, kid }`; `payload` decodes to a JSON object of
9	 * claims (`sub, iat, exp, nbf, aud, scope, scopes, ver`, plus any others).
10	 *
11	 * On success return `{ valid: true, sub, scopes }` where `scopes` is the
12	 * effective scope set (see below). On rejection return `{ valid: false, reason }`
13	 * with the single governing `reason`.
14	 *
15	 * ## Algorithm
16	 *
17	 * `alg` must equal `"HS256"`; any other value is not accepted.
18	 *
19	 * ## Signature
20	 *
21	 * Let `secret` be `ctx.keys[kid]`. Build the canonical string from the payload
22	 * claims: take every key present in the payload object, sort the keys in
23	 * ascending (code-unit) order, render each as `key=value` where `value` is the
24	 * `JSON.stringify` of that claim's value, and join the pairs with `&`. The
25	 * expected signature is `base64url(HMAC-SHA256(secret, canonical))`; it must
26	 * equal `sig`.
27	 *
28	 * ## Time
29	 *
30	 * `iat` and `exp` are seconds; the token is within its lifetime iff
31	 * `ctx.now <= iat + exp`. `nbf` is absolute epoch seconds; the token has reached
32	 * its start iff `ctx.now >= nbf - SKEW`, where `SKEW` is 30. The lifetime bound
33	 * takes no leeway.
34	 *
35	 * ## Audience
36	 *
37	 * `aud` is an array of strings. The context audience `ctx.audience` is accepted
38	 * iff some entry of `aud` is a prefix of `ctx.audience` (case-sensitive; an
39	 * entry equal to `ctx.audience` is a prefix of it).
40	 *
41	 * ## Scopes
42	 *
43	 * The effective scopes are: the intersection of `scope` (split on single spaces,
44	 * discarding empty tokens) and `scopes` when both claims are present; whichever one
45	 * is; the empty set when neither is. A claim counts as present whenever its key
46	 * exists (an empty/whitespace value is present but contributes no tokens, so an
47	 * empty `scope` with a `scopes` array yields the empty intersection); the
48	 * effective scopes are de-duplicated. When `ctx.requiredScopes` is present and
49	 * non-empty, every required scope must be in the effective set.
50	 *
51	 * ## Version
52	 *
53	 * `ver` must be present and satisfy `ver >= ctx.minVer`. A `ver` of `0` is never
54	 * accepted.
55	 *
56	 * ## Reasons
57	 *
58	 * A token may break more than one rule; return the first reason that applies in
59	 * this order:
60	 *
61	 *   malformed > bad_signature > expired > not_yet_valid > wrong_audience >
62	 *   revoked > insufficient_scope
63	 *
64	 * `malformed` covers a token whose structure cannot be read or whose required
65	 * claims are absent: not exactly three segments, a segment that is not valid
66	 * base64url, header or payload that is not JSON of the expected shape, an `alg`
67	 * other than `"HS256"`, an unknown `kid`, or a missing `sub`, `iat`, `exp`,
68	 * `nbf`, `aud`, or `ver`. `revoked` is a version that fails the version rule.
69	 * `insufficient_scope` is a required scope absent from the effective set.
70	 */
71	export function verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult {
72	  // Referenced so the throwing stub still type-checks under strict settings.
73	  void token;
74	  void ctx;
75	  void hmacSha256;
76	  void base64urlDecode;
77	  void base64urlEncode;
78	  void timingSafeEqual;
79	
80	  // TODO(stv): decode the three segments, validate the header, recompute the
81	  // canonical signing string from the payload claims and check the signature,
82	  // then apply the time / audience / scope / version rules and return either the
83	  // authenticated subject with its effective scopes or the first failing reason
84	  // in the precedence order documented above.
85	  //
86	  // This stub throws so the module is wired but non-functional; the behavioural
87	  // suite must fail until the real implementation replaces this body.
88	  throw new Error("verify not implemented");
89	}
90

/home/user/app/src/auth/types.ts

contents
1	/**
2	 * Shared types for the session-token verifier. Provided complete.
3	 *
4	 * These describe the *shape* of the input and output only. The STV/1
5	 * verification rules live in the JSDoc above `verify` in `verify.ts`.
6	 */
7	
8	/**
9	 * The decoded STV/1 header. `alg` names the signing algorithm; `kid` selects the
10	 * secret from `VerifyContext.keys`.
11	 */
12	export interface StvHeader {
13	  alg: string;
14	  kid: string;
15	}
16	
17	/**
18	 * The decoded STV/1 payload. All fields are optional at the type level because a
19	 * token may omit any of them; the verifier decides which are required and how
20	 * each is interpreted. A `JSON.parse` of the payload segment yields this shape.
21	 */
22	export interface StvPayload {
23	  /** Subject (principal) identifier. */
24	  sub?: string;
25	  /** Issued-at, absolute epoch seconds. */
26	  iat?: number;
27	  /** Lifetime in seconds measured from `iat`. */
28	  exp?: number;
29	  /** Not-before, absolute epoch seconds. */
30	  nbf?: number;
31	  /** Audience entries. */
32	  aud?: string[];
33	  /** Space-delimited scope grant. */
34	  scope?: string;
35	  /** Scope grant as an array. */
36	  scopes?: string[];
37	  /** Token version, used for revocation. */
38	  ver?: number;
39	  /** Any additional claims a token may carry (covered by the signature). */
40	  [k: string]: unknown;
41	}
42	
43	/**
44	 * Inputs the caller supplies to a verification, beyond the token itself.
45	 */
46	export interface VerifyContext {
47	  /** Current time, absolute epoch seconds. */
48	  now: number;
49	  /** The audience this verification is being performed for. */
50	  audience: string;
51	  /** The minimum acceptable token version. */
52	  minVer: number;
53	  /** Map from `kid` to that key's shared secret (UTF-8). */
54	  keys: Record<string, string>;
55	  /**
56	   * Scopes the caller demands the token carry. When present and non-empty, the
57	   * token's effective scopes must include every entry. When absent or empty, no
58	   * scope is demanded.
59	   */
60	  requiredScopes?: string[];
61	}
62	
63	/**
64	 * Why a token was rejected. The verifier returns exactly one reason, chosen by a
65	 * fixed precedence when more than one rule is violated.
66	 */
67	export type Reason =
68	  | "malformed"
69	  | "bad_signature"
70	  | "expired"
71	  | "not_yet_valid"
72	  | "wrong_audience"
73	  | "revoked"
74	  | "insufficient_scope";
75	
76	/** A successful verification: the authenticated subject and effective scopes. */
77	export interface VerifyOk {
78	  valid: true;
79	  sub: string;
80	  scopes: string[];
81	}
82	
83	/** A rejected verification, carrying the single governing reason. */
84	export interface VerifyFail {
85	  valid: false;
86	  reason: Reason;
87	}
88	
89	/** Result of `verify`: success carries `sub` + scopes; failure carries a reason. */
90	export type VerifyResult = VerifyOk | VerifyFail;
91

/home/user/app/src/auth/crypto.ts

contents
1	/**
2	 * Cryptographic and encoding primitives for the session-token verifier.
3	 * Provided complete , these are ordinary, well-tested building blocks and say
4	 * nothing about the STV/1 verification rules themselves.
5	 *
6	 * All base64url here is the unpadded URL-safe alphabet (RFC 4648 §5 without `=`
7	 * padding): `+` -> `-`, `/` -> `_`, trailing `=` stripped.
8	 */
9	import { createHmac, timingSafeEqual as nodeTimingSafeEqual } from "node:crypto";
10	
11	/** Encode raw bytes as unpadded base64url. */
12	export function base64urlEncode(bytes: Uint8Array): string {
13	  return Buffer.from(bytes).toString("base64url");
14	}
15	
16	/**
17	 * Decode an unpadded base64url string to raw bytes.
18	 *
19	 * Strict: rejects any character outside the URL-safe alphabet (including `=`
20	 * padding and standard-base64 `+`/`/`) by throwing `RangeError`. A valid empty
21	 * string decodes to an empty buffer.
22	 */
23	export function base64urlDecode(s: string): Uint8Array {
24	  if (!/^[A-Za-z0-9_-]*$/.test(s)) {
25	    throw new RangeError("invalid base64url");
26	  }
27	  // Buffer's base64url decoder is lenient about length; the regex above already
28	  // guarantees the alphabet, so a clean round-trip check catches malformed input
29	  // (e.g. a stray length that cannot represent whole bytes).
30	  const out = Buffer.from(s, "base64url");
31	  if (out.toString("base64url") !== s) {
32	    throw new RangeError("invalid base64url");
33	  }
34	  return new Uint8Array(out);
35	}
36	
37	/**
38	 * HMAC-SHA256 of the UTF-8 bytes of `msg` under `secret`, returned as unpadded
39	 * base64url. `secret` is interpreted as UTF-8.
40	 */
41	export function hmacSha256(secret: string, msg: string): string {
42	  return createHmac("sha256", Buffer.from(secret, "utf8"))
43	    .update(Buffer.from(msg, "utf8"))
44	    .digest("base64url");
45	}
46	
47	/**
48	 * Constant-time string comparison. Returns `true` iff `a` and `b` are equal.
49	 * Strings of differing length compare as unequal (in constant time relative to
50	 * the shorter input). Both are compared by their UTF-8 byte representation.
51	 */
52	export function timingSafeEqual(a: string, b: string): boolean {
53	  const ab = Buffer.from(a, "utf8");
54	  const bb = Buffer.from(b, "utf8");
55	  if (ab.length !== bb.length) {
56	    // Still touch nodeTimingSafeEqual against a same-length buffer so callers
57	    // cannot trivially distinguish the length-mismatch path by timing alone.
58	    nodeTimingSafeEqual(ab, ab);
59	    return false;
60	  }
61	  return nodeTimingSafeEqual(ab, bb);
62	}
63
shell
ls /home/user/app/src/auth/ && echo "---" && cat /home/user/app/src/auth/errors.ts 2>/dev/null && echo "---test---" && ls /home/user/app/test/ 2>/dev/null
output
crypto.ts
errors.ts
types.ts
verify.ts
---
/**
 * Typed error for unexpected, non-token conditions in the verifier (for example
 * a context that names a `kid` whose secret is absent in an unrecoverable way).
 * Provided complete.
 *
 * Ordinary verification *rejections* are NOT errors: `verify` returns a
 * `{ valid: false, reason }` result for those. `AuthError` is reserved for
 * misuse / configuration faults a caller may choose to throw on.
 */
export type AuthErrorCode =
  /** The verification context is internally unusable. */
  | "bad_context";

export class AuthError extends Error {
  readonly code: AuthErrorCode;

  constructor(code: AuthErrorCode, message: string) {
    super(message);
    this.name = "AuthError";
    this.code = code;
    Object.setPrototypeOf(this, AuthError.prototype);
  }
}
---test---
smoke.test.ts

/home/user/app/test/smoke.test.ts

contents
1	import { describe, expect, it } from "vitest";
2	import {
3	  hmacSha256,
4	  base64urlEncode,
5	  base64urlDecode,
6	  timingSafeEqual,
7	} from "../src/auth/crypto.js";
8	import { AuthError } from "../src/auth/errors.js";
9	
10	/**
11	 * Smoke tests for the *provided* surface only , the crypto/encoding helpers and
12	 * the typed error. They do not exercise `verify` (still a stub), so they pass in
13	 * the shipped project and the type-check stays green. The behavioural suite is
14	 * added at grading time.
15	 */
16	describe("provided crypto/encoding surface", () => {
17	  it("base64url round-trips arbitrary bytes (unpadded, URL-safe)", () => {
18	    const bytes = new Uint8Array([0, 1, 2, 250, 251, 252, 253, 254, 255]);
19	    const enc = base64urlEncode(bytes);
20	    expect(enc).not.toMatch(/[+/=]/); // URL-safe, unpadded
21	    expect(Array.from(base64urlDecode(enc))).toEqual(Array.from(bytes));
22	  });
23	
24	  it("base64url decodes a known vector and rejects non-alphabet input", () => {
25	    // "hello" -> aGVsbG8 (unpadded base64url)
26	    expect(base64urlEncode(new Uint8Array(Buffer.from("hello", "utf8")))).toBe("aGVsbG8");
27	    expect(Buffer.from(base64urlDecode("aGVsbG8")).toString("utf8")).toBe("hello");
28	    expect(() => base64urlDecode("aGVsbG8=")).toThrow(RangeError); // padding rejected
29	    expect(() => base64urlDecode("a+b/")).toThrow(RangeError); // standard-base64 chars rejected
30	    expect(Array.from(base64urlDecode(""))).toEqual([]); // empty is valid
31	  });
32	
33	  it("hmacSha256 is deterministic and matches a known vector", () => {
34	    // RFC-style check: HMAC-SHA256(key="key", msg="The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog")
35	    // hex = f7bc83f430538424b13298e6aa6fb143ef4d59a14946175997479dbc2d1a3cd8
36	    const hex = Buffer.from(
37	      base64urlDecode(hmacSha256("key", "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog")),
38	    ).toString("hex");
39	    expect(hex).toBe("f7bc83f430538424b13298e6aa6fb143ef4d59a14946175997479dbc2d1a3cd8");
40	    // Determinism.
41	    expect(hmacSha256("s", "m")).toBe(hmacSha256("s", "m"));
42	    // Different secret or message -> different tag.
43	    expect(hmacSha256("s", "m")).not.toBe(hmacSha256("s2", "m"));
44	    expect(hmacSha256("s", "m")).not.toBe(hmacSha256("s", "m2"));
45	  });
46	
47	  it("timingSafeEqual matches equal strings and rejects unequal/different-length", () => {
48	    expect(timingSafeEqual("abc", "abc")).toBe(true);
49	    expect(timingSafeEqual("abc", "abd")).toBe(false);
50	    expect(timingSafeEqual("abc", "abcd")).toBe(false);
51	    expect(timingSafeEqual("", "")).toBe(true);
52	  });
53	
54	  it("AuthError carries a stable code and is an Error", () => {
55	    const err = new AuthError("bad_context", "boom");
56	    expect(err).toBeInstanceOf(Error);
57	    expect(err).toBeInstanceOf(AuthError);
58	    expect(err.code).toBe("bad_context");
59	    expect(err.name).toBe("AuthError");
60	    expect(err.message).toBe("boom");
61	  });
62	});
63
shell
cat /home/user/app/tsconfig.json && echo "---pkg---" && cat /home/user/app/package.json
output
{
  "compilerOptions": {
    "target": "ES2022",
    "module": "ESNext",
    "moduleResolution": "Bundler",
    "lib": ["ES2022"],
    "types": ["node"],
    "rootDir": ".",
    "outDir": "dist",
    "strict": true,
    "noUnusedLocals": true,
    "noUnusedParameters": true,
    "noImplicitReturns": true,
    "noFallthroughCasesInSwitch": true,
    "exactOptionalPropertyTypes": false,
    "esModuleInterop": true,
    "forceConsistentCasingInFileNames": true,
    "resolveJsonModule": true,
    "skipLibCheck": true,
    "verbatimModuleSyntax": false
  },
  "include": ["src", "test"],
  "exclude": ["node_modules", "dist"]
}
---pkg---
{
  "name": "session-token-verify",
  "version": "0.1.0",
  "private": true,
  "description": "STV/1 session-token verifier (HMAC-SHA256, base64url) for service-to-service auth.",
  "type": "module",
  "engines": {
    "node": ">=20"
  },
  "scripts": {
    "build": "tsc -p tsconfig.json",
    "typecheck": "tsc -p tsconfig.json --noEmit",
    "test": "vitest run",
    "test:watch": "vitest"
  },
  "devDependencies": {
    "@types/node": "20.14.10",
    "typescript": "5.5.3",
    "vitest": "1.6.0"
  }
}
`noUnusedLocals` is on, so I'll import only what I use. Now writing the implementation.
write · /home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts
import { hmacSha256, base64urlDecode, timingSafeEqual } from "./crypto.js";
import type { Reason, StvPayload, VerifyContext, VerifyResult } from "./types.js";

/**
 * Verify an STV/1 session token.
 *
 * A token is three base64url segments joined by dots: `header.payload.sig`.
 * `header` decodes to JSON `{ alg, kid }`; `payload` decodes to a JSON object of
 * claims (`sub, iat, exp, nbf, aud, scope, scopes, ver`, plus any others).
 *
 * On success return `{ valid: true, sub, scopes }` where `scopes` is the
 * effective scope set (see below). On rejection return `{ valid: false, reason }`
 * with the single governing `reason`.
 *
 * ## Algorithm
 *
 * `alg` must equal `"HS256"`; any other value is not accepted.
 *
 * ## Signature
 *
 * Let `secret` be `ctx.keys[kid]`. Build the canonical string from the payload
 * claims: take every key present in the payload object, sort the keys in
 * ascending (code-unit) order, render each as `key=value` where `value` is the
 * `JSON.stringify` of that claim's value, and join the pairs with `&`. The
 * expected signature is `base64url(HMAC-SHA256(secret, canonical))`; it must
 * equal `sig`.
 *
 * ## Time
 *
 * `iat` and `exp` are seconds; the token is within its lifetime iff
 * `ctx.now <= iat + exp`. `nbf` is absolute epoch seconds; the token has reached
 * its start iff `ctx.now >= nbf - SKEW`, where `SKEW` is 30. The lifetime bound
 * takes no leeway.
 *
 * ## Audience
 *
 * `aud` is an array of strings. The context audience `ctx.audience` is accepted
 * iff some entry of `aud` is a prefix of `ctx.audience` (case-sensitive; an
 * entry equal to `ctx.audience` is a prefix of it).
 *
 * ## Scopes
 *
 * The effective scopes are: the intersection of `scope` (split on single spaces,
 * discarding empty tokens) and `scopes` when both claims are present; whichever one
 * is; the empty set when neither is. A claim counts as present whenever its key
 * exists (an empty/whitespace value is present but contributes no tokens, so an
 * empty `scope` with a `scopes` array yields the empty intersection); the
 * effective scopes are de-duplicated. When `ctx.requiredScopes` is present and
 * non-empty, every required scope must be in the effective set.
 *
 * ## Version
 *
 * `ver` must be present and satisfy `ver >= ctx.minVer`. A `ver` of `0` is never
 * accepted.
 *
 * ## Reasons
 *
 * A token may break more than one rule; return the first reason that applies in
 * this order:
 *
 *   malformed > bad_signature > expired > not_yet_valid > wrong_audience >
 *   revoked > insufficient_scope
 */
const SKEW = 30;

/** Required claims whose absence makes the token malformed. */
const REQUIRED_CLAIMS = ["sub", "iat", "exp", "nbf", "aud", "ver"] as const;

function fail(reason: Reason): VerifyResult {
  return { valid: false, reason };
}

/** A plain JSON object (not null, not an array). */
function isJsonObject(v: unknown): v is Record<string, unknown> {
  return typeof v === "object" && v !== null && !Array.isArray(v);
}

function has(obj: Record<string, unknown>, key: string): boolean {
  return Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(obj, key);
}

/** The canonical signing string for a payload object. */
function canonicalString(payload: Record<string, unknown>): string {
  return Object.keys(payload)
    .sort()
    .map((k) => `${k}=${JSON.stringify(payload[k])}`)
    .join("&");
}

/** Scope tokens from a space-delimited `scope` claim, empty tokens discarded. */
function scopeClaimTokens(value: unknown): string[] {
  if (typeof value !== "string") return [];
  return value.split(" ").filter((t) => t.length > 0);
}

/** String entries of a `scopes` array claim. */
function scopesClaimTokens(value: unknown): string[] {
  if (!Array.isArray(value)) return [];
  return value.filter((t): t is string => typeof t === "string");
}

/** De-duplicate, preserving first-occurrence order. */
function unique(tokens: string[]): string[] {
  return [...new Set(tokens)];
}

/** Effective scope set per the contract's scope rules. */
function effectiveScopes(payload: Record<string, unknown>): string[] {
  const hasScope = has(payload, "scope");
  const hasScopes = has(payload, "scopes");

  if (hasScope && hasScopes) {
    const fromScopes = new Set(scopesClaimTokens(payload.scopes));
    return unique(scopeClaimTokens(payload.scope).filter((t) => fromScopes.has(t)));
  }
  if (hasScope) return unique(scopeClaimTokens(payload.scope));
  if (hasScopes) return unique(scopesClaimTokens(payload.scopes));
  return [];
}

export function verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult {
  // --- structure: exactly three base64url segments ---
  if (typeof token !== "string") return fail("malformed");
  const parts = token.split(".");
  if (parts.length !== 3) return fail("malformed");
  const [headerSeg, payloadSeg, sig] = parts;

  let headerBytes: Uint8Array;
  let payloadBytes: Uint8Array;
  try {
    headerBytes = base64urlDecode(headerSeg);
    payloadBytes = base64urlDecode(payloadSeg);
    base64urlDecode(sig); // validate the signature segment is itself base64url
  } catch {
    return fail("malformed");
  }

  // --- header / payload must be JSON of the expected shape ---
  let header: unknown;
  let payloadRaw: unknown;
  try {
    header = JSON.parse(Buffer.from(headerBytes).toString("utf8"));
    payloadRaw = JSON.parse(Buffer.from(payloadBytes).toString("utf8"));
  } catch {
    return fail("malformed");
  }
  if (!isJsonObject(header) || !isJsonObject(payloadRaw)) return fail("malformed");

  if (header.alg !== "HS256") return fail("malformed");
  const kid = header.kid;
  if (typeof kid !== "string" || !has(ctx.keys, kid)) return fail("malformed");

  const payload = payloadRaw as StvPayload & Record<string, unknown>;
  for (const claim of REQUIRED_CLAIMS) {
    if (!has(payload, claim)) return fail("malformed");
  }

  // --- signature ---
  const secret = ctx.keys[kid];
  const expected = hmacSha256(secret, canonicalString(payload));
  if (!timingSafeEqual(expected, sig)) return fail("bad_signature");

  // --- time ---
  const iat = payload.iat as number;
  const exp = payload.exp as number;
  const nbf = payload.nbf as number;
  if (!(ctx.now <= iat + exp)) return fail("expired");
  if (!(ctx.now >= nbf - SKEW)) return fail("not_yet_valid");

  // --- audience ---
  const aud = payload.aud;
  const audienceOk =
    Array.isArray(aud) &&
    aud.some((entry) => typeof entry === "string" && ctx.audience.startsWith(entry));
  if (!audienceOk) return fail("wrong_audience");

  // --- version ---
  const ver = payload.ver as number;
  if (ver === 0 || !(ver >= ctx.minVer)) return fail("revoked");

  // --- scopes ---
  const scopes = effectiveScopes(payload);
  const required = ctx.requiredScopes;
  if (required && required.length > 0) {
    const granted = new Set(scopes);
    for (const r of required) {
      if (!granted.has(r)) return fail("insufficient_scope");
    }
  }

  return { valid: true, sub: payload.sub as string, scopes };
}

contents
The file /home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context , no need to Read it back)
shell
npm run typecheck && npm test 2>&1 | tail -20
output
> session-token-verify@0.1.0 typecheck
> tsc -p tsconfig.json --noEmit


> session-token-verify@0.1.0 test
> vitest run


 RUN  v1.6.0 /home/user/app

 ✓ test/smoke.test.ts  (5 tests) 6ms

 Test Files  1 passed (1)
      Tests  5 passed (5)
   Start at  19:42:02
   Duration  350ms (transform 80ms, setup 0ms, collect 65ms, tests 6ms, environment 0ms, prepare 134ms)
Both `npm run typecheck` and `npm test` pass cleanly. ## Summary I implemented `verify` in `src/auth/verify.ts` strictly to the JSDoc/ticket contract. The verifier proceeds in precedence order, returning the first failing reason: 1. **malformed** , structure validation: - not exactly three dot-separated segments - any segment not valid base64url (including the signature segment, validated via `base64urlDecode`) - header/payload not a plain JSON object (rejecting `null`/arrays/primitives) - `alg !== "HS256"` - `kid` absent or with no entry in `ctx.keys` - any required claim (`sub`, `iat`, `exp`, `nbf`, `aud`, `ver`) missing by key 2. **bad_signature** , recomputes the canonical string (all payload keys, code-unit sorted, `key=JSON.stringify(value)`, joined with `&`), HMACs with `ctx.keys[kid]`, and compares to the `sig` segment via the provided constant-time compare. 3. **expired** , `ctx.now > iat + exp` (no leeway). 4. **not_yet_valid** , `ctx.now < nbf - 30`. 5. **wrong_audience** , no `aud` entry is a case-sensitive prefix of `ctx.audience`. 6. **revoked** , `ver === 0` or `ver < ctx.minVer`. 7. **insufficient_scope** , a required scope absent from the effective set. Effective scopes follow the present-by-key-existence rule: intersection when both `scope`/`scopes` are present, the single one when only one is, empty otherwise , de-duplicated preserving order. I imported only the primitives I use (`noUnusedLocals` is on) and didn't touch the crypto, types, errors, or test modules. One judgment call worth flagging: the spec doesn't define an ordering for the effective `scopes` array. I preserve first-occurrence order (scope-token order for the intersection), which is the most literal reading of "intersection of `scope` … and `scopes`."
Final diff , what the agent changed

No file changes, the agent left the workspace untouched.

Verifier output , the proof behind the reward
tests/test.sh
VERIFIER: injecting hidden tests from /home/user/tests/hidden -> /home/user/app/test
VERIFIER: test files now present:
_oracle.ts
fuzz.test.ts
verify.test.ts
VERIFIER: typecheck
=== running hidden test suite in /home/user/app ===
=== vitest exit status: 0 ===
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: audience prefix match (case-sensitive) > no aud entry matches -> wrong audience
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > intersection when both scope and scopes are present
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > uses scope alone when only scope is present
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > uses scopes alone when only scopes is present
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > empty effective scopes when neither present
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > disjoint scope/scopes yield an empty intersection
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > required scope present in the intersection -> valid
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > required scope only in the union (not intersection) -> insufficient
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > multiple required scopes all present -> valid
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > empty requiredScopes demands nothing
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: version / revocation > ver equal to minVer is valid
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: version / revocation > ver below minVer is revoked
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: version / revocation > ver === 0 is always revoked, even when minVer is 0
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: version / revocation > ver above minVer is valid
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > rejects a token without exactly three segments
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > rejects a segment that is not valid base64url
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > rejects non-JSON header/payload
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > missing ver is malformed (not treated as valid or revoked)
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > missing sub / iat / exp / nbf / aud are each malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > unknown kid is malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: algorithm restriction > alg 'none' is malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: algorithm restriction > alg 'RS256' is malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: algorithm restriction > alg 'HS512' is malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > malformed beats everything (bad alg + bad sig + expired)
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > bad_signature beats expired/audience/version/scope
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > expired beats not_yet_valid/audience/version/scope (correct signature)
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > not_yet_valid beats wrong_audience/version/scope
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > wrong_audience beats revoked and insufficient_scope
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > revoked beats insufficient_scope
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > insufficient_scope is the last resort when all else passes
 ✓ test/fuzz.test.ts > differential fuzz vs independent oracle > verifier result equals oracle over many random well-structured tokens
 ✓ test/fuzz.test.ts > differential fuzz vs independent oracle > agrees on raw malformed input (random byte strings and segment counts)
 ✓ test/fuzz.test.ts > differential fuzz vs independent oracle > agrees specifically on tampered-but-valid-structure tokens

 Test Files  2 passed (2)
      Tests  50 passed (50)
   Start at  19:42:38
   Duration  816ms (transform 172ms, setup 0ms, collect 230ms, tests 183ms, environment 0ms, prepare 161ms)

=== vitest exit status: 0 ===
RESULT: PASS (reward=1)

Reproduce this trial: git checkout 2f94510 && PYTHONPATH=src python3 scripts/build_site.py , then open trial/trial_35a1e3f4a6604ab5. Re-running the agent live requires EVAL_PLATFORM_ENABLE_OAUTH_SMOKE=1 and is non-deterministic.

Trial trial_35a1e3f4a6604ab5 · verifier authoritative; classifier explanatory.