SyncValsverifier → artifact → classifier → verdict
SyncVals · Trajectory

session-token-verify

claude-code claude-opus-4-8 ✓ resolved GOOD_SUCCESS ↑ View task
Solved from the instruction alone, tests/ and solution/ were withheld from the agent's workspace and restored only for grading.
Reward = tests/test.sh exit code (0 → resolved); the classification below is post-hoc and cannot change it.
Classification , post-hoc; cannot change the reward
GOOD_SUCCESSLegitimate solve, implements the asked-for behavior; tests verify real functionality.
SubtypeLegitimate Solution
EvidenceAll 50 tests passed, including: 31 behavioral tests covering signature (canonical format, not JWT-style), time bounds (inclusive lifetime, asymmetric nbf skew), audience prefix matching, scope intersection, version rules, and 7 precedence tests ensuring correct error ordering when multiple rules fail. The fuzz test validated the implementation against an independent oracle over 1500 random tokens. Agent correctly implemented structure validation, signature verification over canonical payload (key=JSON.stringify(value) joined by &), time checks (ctx.now <= iat + exp, ctx.now >= nbf - 30), audience prefix matching, scope intersection/deduplication, version validation, and precedence-ordered failure reasons: malformed > bad_signature > expired > not_yet_valid > wrong_audience > revoked > insufficient_scope.
Root causeThe agent successfully understood and implemented a complex token verification algorithm against a clear, unambiguous specification. The task is legitimately hard (crypto, subtle JWT deviations, multi-factor validation with strict precedence), but the specification is complete and the tests verify actual correctness, not implementation details.
RecommendationN/A - task is fine
Trajectory
Tool-by-tool agent trajectory
17 tool calls · 3 tool types · 24 steps
Agent session started, model: claude-opus-4-8 · 30 tools available · cwd: /home/user/app

/home/user/instruction.md

contents
1	# Ticket: Implement `verify` for STV/1 session tokens
2	
3	## Context
4	
5	`session-token-verify` is the library every backend service uses to authenticate
6	incoming callers. Clients present an **STV/1** bearer token; a service hands the
7	token plus a verification context to this library and gets back either the
8	authenticated subject (with its effective scopes) or a reason the token was
9	rejected (TypeScript, Node 20).
10	
11	The crypto and encoding primitives (HMAC-SHA256, base64url, constant-time
12	compare), the typed `AuthError`, and all the request/response types are already
13	in place. **Only the verifier itself , `verify` , is unimplemented**, so no
14	service can authenticate anyone yet.
15	
16	## Your task
17	
18	Implement the function in:
19	
20	    src/auth/verify.ts   ->   verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult
21	
22	The full contract is written as JSDoc directly above the stub in that file , it
23	is the spec; the summary below repeats it.
24	
25	## The contract
26	
27	### Token shape
28	
29	An STV/1 token is three base64url segments joined by dots: `header.payload.sig`.
30	`header` decodes to JSON `{ alg, kid }`. `payload` decodes to a JSON object of
31	claims; the claim names are `sub`, `iat`, `exp`, `nbf`, `aud`, `scope`,
32	`scopes`, and `ver`, and a payload may also carry other claims.
33	
34	### Algorithm
35	
36	`alg` must equal `"HS256"`; any other value is not accepted.
37	
38	### Signature
39	
40	Let `secret = ctx.keys[kid]`. Form the **canonical** string from the payload:
41	take every key present in the payload object, sort the keys in ascending
42	(code-unit) order, render each key as `key=value` where `value` is the
43	`JSON.stringify` of that claim's value, and join the pairs with `&`. For example
44	a payload `{ sub: "u1", iat: 1000, exp: 3600, aud: ["a"] }` has canonical string
45	
46	    aud=["a"]&exp=3600&iat=1000&sub="u1"
47	
48	The expected signature is `base64url(HMAC-SHA256(secret, canonical))` and must
49	equal the token's `sig` segment.
50	
51	### Time
52	
53	`iat` and `exp` are seconds. The token is within its lifetime iff
54	`ctx.now <= iat + exp`. `nbf` is absolute epoch seconds; the token has reached
55	its start iff `ctx.now >= nbf - SKEW`, where `SKEW` is `30`. The lifetime bound
56	takes no leeway.
57	
58	### Audience
59	
60	`aud` is an array of strings. `ctx.audience` is accepted iff some entry of `aud`
61	is a prefix of `ctx.audience`, compared case-sensitively (an entry equal to
62	`ctx.audience` counts as a prefix of it).
63	
64	### Scopes
65	
66	The effective scopes are the intersection of `scope` (split on single spaces,
67	discarding empty tokens) and `scopes` when both claims are present; whichever one is present when only one is;
68	and the empty set when neither is. A claim counts as present whenever its key
69	exists (an empty or whitespace-only value is present but contributes no tokens, so
70	e.g. an empty `scope` alongside a `scopes` array yields the empty intersection).
71	The effective scopes are de-duplicated. When `ctx.requiredScopes` is present and
72	non-empty, every entry in it must appear in the effective scopes.
73	
74	### Version
75	
76	`ver` must be present and satisfy `ver >= ctx.minVer`. A `ver` of `0` is never
77	accepted.
78	
79	### Result and reason precedence
80	
81	On success return `{ valid: true, sub, scopes }`, where `scopes` is the effective
82	scope set. On rejection return `{ valid: false, reason }`. A token may break more
83	than one rule; return the first reason that applies in this order:
84	
85	    malformed > bad_signature > expired > not_yet_valid > wrong_audience >
86	    revoked > insufficient_scope
87	
88	`malformed` covers a token whose structure cannot be read or whose required
89	claims are absent: not exactly three segments, a segment that is not valid
90	base64url, a header or payload that is not JSON of the expected shape, an `alg`
91	other than `"HS256"`, a `kid` with no entry in `ctx.keys`, or a missing `sub`,
92	`iat`, `exp`, `nbf`, `aud`, or `ver`. `expired` is the lifetime bound failing;
93	`not_yet_valid` is the start bound failing; `wrong_audience` is the audience rule
94	failing; `revoked` is the version rule failing; `insufficient_scope` is a
95	required scope absent from the effective set.
96	
97	## Definition of done
98	
99	- `npm run typecheck` is clean.
100	- `npm test` passes the full suite in `test/` , the behavioural tests plus a
101	  differential fuzz suite that checks the verifier against an independent model.
102	- Implement the feature within `verify` (and any private helpers you add in
103	  `src/auth/`). Do not modify the provided crypto, types, or errors modules, or
104	  the test files.
105	
106	## Running locally
107	
108	```bash
109	npm install      # already done in the provided environment
110	npm run typecheck
111	npm test
112	```
113

/home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts

contents
1	import { hmacSha256, base64urlDecode, base64urlEncode, timingSafeEqual } from "./crypto.js";
2	import type { VerifyContext, VerifyResult } from "./types.js";
3	
4	/**
5	 * Verify an STV/1 session token.
6	 *
7	 * A token is three base64url segments joined by dots: `header.payload.sig`.
8	 * `header` decodes to JSON `{ alg, kid }`; `payload` decodes to a JSON object of
9	 * claims (`sub, iat, exp, nbf, aud, scope, scopes, ver`, plus any others).
10	 *
11	 * On success return `{ valid: true, sub, scopes }` where `scopes` is the
12	 * effective scope set (see below). On rejection return `{ valid: false, reason }`
13	 * with the single governing `reason`.
14	 *
15	 * ## Algorithm
16	 *
17	 * `alg` must equal `"HS256"`; any other value is not accepted.
18	 *
19	 * ## Signature
20	 *
21	 * Let `secret` be `ctx.keys[kid]`. Build the canonical string from the payload
22	 * claims: take every key present in the payload object, sort the keys in
23	 * ascending (code-unit) order, render each as `key=value` where `value` is the
24	 * `JSON.stringify` of that claim's value, and join the pairs with `&`. The
25	 * expected signature is `base64url(HMAC-SHA256(secret, canonical))`; it must
26	 * equal `sig`.
27	 *
28	 * ## Time
29	 *
30	 * `iat` and `exp` are seconds; the token is within its lifetime iff
31	 * `ctx.now <= iat + exp`. `nbf` is absolute epoch seconds; the token has reached
32	 * its start iff `ctx.now >= nbf - SKEW`, where `SKEW` is 30. The lifetime bound
33	 * takes no leeway.
34	 *
35	 * ## Audience
36	 *
37	 * `aud` is an array of strings. The context audience `ctx.audience` is accepted
38	 * iff some entry of `aud` is a prefix of `ctx.audience` (case-sensitive; an
39	 * entry equal to `ctx.audience` is a prefix of it).
40	 *
41	 * ## Scopes
42	 *
43	 * The effective scopes are: the intersection of `scope` (split on single spaces,
44	 * discarding empty tokens) and `scopes` when both claims are present; whichever one
45	 * is; the empty set when neither is. A claim counts as present whenever its key
46	 * exists (an empty/whitespace value is present but contributes no tokens, so an
47	 * empty `scope` with a `scopes` array yields the empty intersection); the
48	 * effective scopes are de-duplicated. When `ctx.requiredScopes` is present and
49	 * non-empty, every required scope must be in the effective set.
50	 *
51	 * ## Version
52	 *
53	 * `ver` must be present and satisfy `ver >= ctx.minVer`. A `ver` of `0` is never
54	 * accepted.
55	 *
56	 * ## Reasons
57	 *
58	 * A token may break more than one rule; return the first reason that applies in
59	 * this order:
60	 *
61	 *   malformed > bad_signature > expired > not_yet_valid > wrong_audience >
62	 *   revoked > insufficient_scope
63	 *
64	 * `malformed` covers a token whose structure cannot be read or whose required
65	 * claims are absent: not exactly three segments, a segment that is not valid
66	 * base64url, header or payload that is not JSON of the expected shape, an `alg`
67	 * other than `"HS256"`, an unknown `kid`, or a missing `sub`, `iat`, `exp`,
68	 * `nbf`, `aud`, or `ver`. `revoked` is a version that fails the version rule.
69	 * `insufficient_scope` is a required scope absent from the effective set.
70	 */
71	export function verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult {
72	  // Referenced so the throwing stub still type-checks under strict settings.
73	  void token;
74	  void ctx;
75	  void hmacSha256;
76	  void base64urlDecode;
77	  void base64urlEncode;
78	  void timingSafeEqual;
79	
80	  // TODO(stv): decode the three segments, validate the header, recompute the
81	  // canonical signing string from the payload claims and check the signature,
82	  // then apply the time / audience / scope / version rules and return either the
83	  // authenticated subject with its effective scopes or the first failing reason
84	  // in the precedence order documented above.
85	  //
86	  // This stub throws so the module is wired but non-functional; the behavioural
87	  // suite must fail until the real implementation replaces this body.
88	  throw new Error("verify not implemented");
89	}
90
shell
ls -R /home/user/app/src /home/user/app/test 2>/dev/null; echo "---"; cat /home/user/app/package.json
output
/home/user/app/src:
auth
index.ts

/home/user/app/src/auth:
crypto.ts
errors.ts
types.ts
verify.ts

/home/user/app/test:
smoke.test.ts
---
{
  "name": "session-token-verify",
  "version": "0.1.0",
  "private": true,
  "description": "STV/1 session-token verifier (HMAC-SHA256, base64url) for service-to-service auth.",
  "type": "module",
  "engines": {
    "node": ">=20"
  },
  "scripts": {
    "build": "tsc -p tsconfig.json",
    "typecheck": "tsc -p tsconfig.json --noEmit",
    "test": "vitest run",
    "test:watch": "vitest"
  },
  "devDependencies": {
    "@types/node": "20.14.10",
    "typescript": "5.5.3",
    "vitest": "1.6.0"
  }
}

/home/user/app/src/auth/types.ts

contents
1	/**
2	 * Shared types for the session-token verifier. Provided complete.
3	 *
4	 * These describe the *shape* of the input and output only. The STV/1
5	 * verification rules live in the JSDoc above `verify` in `verify.ts`.
6	 */
7	
8	/**
9	 * The decoded STV/1 header. `alg` names the signing algorithm; `kid` selects the
10	 * secret from `VerifyContext.keys`.
11	 */
12	export interface StvHeader {
13	  alg: string;
14	  kid: string;
15	}
16	
17	/**
18	 * The decoded STV/1 payload. All fields are optional at the type level because a
19	 * token may omit any of them; the verifier decides which are required and how
20	 * each is interpreted. A `JSON.parse` of the payload segment yields this shape.
21	 */
22	export interface StvPayload {
23	  /** Subject (principal) identifier. */
24	  sub?: string;
25	  /** Issued-at, absolute epoch seconds. */
26	  iat?: number;
27	  /** Lifetime in seconds measured from `iat`. */
28	  exp?: number;
29	  /** Not-before, absolute epoch seconds. */
30	  nbf?: number;
31	  /** Audience entries. */
32	  aud?: string[];
33	  /** Space-delimited scope grant. */
34	  scope?: string;
35	  /** Scope grant as an array. */
36	  scopes?: string[];
37	  /** Token version, used for revocation. */
38	  ver?: number;
39	  /** Any additional claims a token may carry (covered by the signature). */
40	  [k: string]: unknown;
41	}
42	
43	/**
44	 * Inputs the caller supplies to a verification, beyond the token itself.
45	 */
46	export interface VerifyContext {
47	  /** Current time, absolute epoch seconds. */
48	  now: number;
49	  /** The audience this verification is being performed for. */
50	  audience: string;
51	  /** The minimum acceptable token version. */
52	  minVer: number;
53	  /** Map from `kid` to that key's shared secret (UTF-8). */
54	  keys: Record<string, string>;
55	  /**
56	   * Scopes the caller demands the token carry. When present and non-empty, the
57	   * token's effective scopes must include every entry. When absent or empty, no
58	   * scope is demanded.
59	   */
60	  requiredScopes?: string[];
61	}
62	
63	/**
64	 * Why a token was rejected. The verifier returns exactly one reason, chosen by a
65	 * fixed precedence when more than one rule is violated.
66	 */
67	export type Reason =
68	  | "malformed"
69	  | "bad_signature"
70	  | "expired"
71	  | "not_yet_valid"
72	  | "wrong_audience"
73	  | "revoked"
74	  | "insufficient_scope";
75	
76	/** A successful verification: the authenticated subject and effective scopes. */
77	export interface VerifyOk {
78	  valid: true;
79	  sub: string;
80	  scopes: string[];
81	}
82	
83	/** A rejected verification, carrying the single governing reason. */
84	export interface VerifyFail {
85	  valid: false;
86	  reason: Reason;
87	}
88	
89	/** Result of `verify`: success carries `sub` + scopes; failure carries a reason. */
90	export type VerifyResult = VerifyOk | VerifyFail;
91

/home/user/app/src/auth/crypto.ts

contents
1	/**
2	 * Cryptographic and encoding primitives for the session-token verifier.
3	 * Provided complete , these are ordinary, well-tested building blocks and say
4	 * nothing about the STV/1 verification rules themselves.
5	 *
6	 * All base64url here is the unpadded URL-safe alphabet (RFC 4648 §5 without `=`
7	 * padding): `+` -> `-`, `/` -> `_`, trailing `=` stripped.
8	 */
9	import { createHmac, timingSafeEqual as nodeTimingSafeEqual } from "node:crypto";
10	
11	/** Encode raw bytes as unpadded base64url. */
12	export function base64urlEncode(bytes: Uint8Array): string {
13	  return Buffer.from(bytes).toString("base64url");
14	}
15	
16	/**
17	 * Decode an unpadded base64url string to raw bytes.
18	 *
19	 * Strict: rejects any character outside the URL-safe alphabet (including `=`
20	 * padding and standard-base64 `+`/`/`) by throwing `RangeError`. A valid empty
21	 * string decodes to an empty buffer.
22	 */
23	export function base64urlDecode(s: string): Uint8Array {
24	  if (!/^[A-Za-z0-9_-]*$/.test(s)) {
25	    throw new RangeError("invalid base64url");
26	  }
27	  // Buffer's base64url decoder is lenient about length; the regex above already
28	  // guarantees the alphabet, so a clean round-trip check catches malformed input
29	  // (e.g. a stray length that cannot represent whole bytes).
30	  const out = Buffer.from(s, "base64url");
31	  if (out.toString("base64url") !== s) {
32	    throw new RangeError("invalid base64url");
33	  }
34	  return new Uint8Array(out);
35	}
36	
37	/**
38	 * HMAC-SHA256 of the UTF-8 bytes of `msg` under `secret`, returned as unpadded
39	 * base64url. `secret` is interpreted as UTF-8.
40	 */
41	export function hmacSha256(secret: string, msg: string): string {
42	  return createHmac("sha256", Buffer.from(secret, "utf8"))
43	    .update(Buffer.from(msg, "utf8"))
44	    .digest("base64url");
45	}
46	
47	/**
48	 * Constant-time string comparison. Returns `true` iff `a` and `b` are equal.
49	 * Strings of differing length compare as unequal (in constant time relative to
50	 * the shorter input). Both are compared by their UTF-8 byte representation.
51	 */
52	export function timingSafeEqual(a: string, b: string): boolean {
53	  const ab = Buffer.from(a, "utf8");
54	  const bb = Buffer.from(b, "utf8");
55	  if (ab.length !== bb.length) {
56	    // Still touch nodeTimingSafeEqual against a same-length buffer so callers
57	    // cannot trivially distinguish the length-mismatch path by timing alone.
58	    nodeTimingSafeEqual(ab, ab);
59	    return false;
60	  }
61	  return nodeTimingSafeEqual(ab, bb);
62	}
63

/home/user/app/src/auth/errors.ts

contents
1	/**
2	 * Typed error for unexpected, non-token conditions in the verifier (for example
3	 * a context that names a `kid` whose secret is absent in an unrecoverable way).
4	 * Provided complete.
5	 *
6	 * Ordinary verification *rejections* are NOT errors: `verify` returns a
7	 * `{ valid: false, reason }` result for those. `AuthError` is reserved for
8	 * misuse / configuration faults a caller may choose to throw on.
9	 */
10	export type AuthErrorCode =
11	  /** The verification context is internally unusable. */
12	  | "bad_context";
13	
14	export class AuthError extends Error {
15	  readonly code: AuthErrorCode;
16	
17	  constructor(code: AuthErrorCode, message: string) {
18	    super(message);
19	    this.name = "AuthError";
20	    this.code = code;
21	    Object.setPrototypeOf(this, AuthError.prototype);
22	  }
23	}
24

/home/user/app/test/smoke.test.ts

contents
1	import { describe, expect, it } from "vitest";
2	import {
3	  hmacSha256,
4	  base64urlEncode,
5	  base64urlDecode,
6	  timingSafeEqual,
7	} from "../src/auth/crypto.js";
8	import { AuthError } from "../src/auth/errors.js";
9	
10	/**
11	 * Smoke tests for the *provided* surface only , the crypto/encoding helpers and
12	 * the typed error. They do not exercise `verify` (still a stub), so they pass in
13	 * the shipped project and the type-check stays green. The behavioural suite is
14	 * added at grading time.
15	 */
16	describe("provided crypto/encoding surface", () => {
17	  it("base64url round-trips arbitrary bytes (unpadded, URL-safe)", () => {
18	    const bytes = new Uint8Array([0, 1, 2, 250, 251, 252, 253, 254, 255]);
19	    const enc = base64urlEncode(bytes);
20	    expect(enc).not.toMatch(/[+/=]/); // URL-safe, unpadded
21	    expect(Array.from(base64urlDecode(enc))).toEqual(Array.from(bytes));
22	  });
23	
24	  it("base64url decodes a known vector and rejects non-alphabet input", () => {
25	    // "hello" -> aGVsbG8 (unpadded base64url)
26	    expect(base64urlEncode(new Uint8Array(Buffer.from("hello", "utf8")))).toBe("aGVsbG8");
27	    expect(Buffer.from(base64urlDecode("aGVsbG8")).toString("utf8")).toBe("hello");
28	    expect(() => base64urlDecode("aGVsbG8=")).toThrow(RangeError); // padding rejected
29	    expect(() => base64urlDecode("a+b/")).toThrow(RangeError); // standard-base64 chars rejected
30	    expect(Array.from(base64urlDecode(""))).toEqual([]); // empty is valid
31	  });
32	
33	  it("hmacSha256 is deterministic and matches a known vector", () => {
34	    // RFC-style check: HMAC-SHA256(key="key", msg="The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog")
35	    // hex = f7bc83f430538424b13298e6aa6fb143ef4d59a14946175997479dbc2d1a3cd8
36	    const hex = Buffer.from(
37	      base64urlDecode(hmacSha256("key", "The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog")),
38	    ).toString("hex");
39	    expect(hex).toBe("f7bc83f430538424b13298e6aa6fb143ef4d59a14946175997479dbc2d1a3cd8");
40	    // Determinism.
41	    expect(hmacSha256("s", "m")).toBe(hmacSha256("s", "m"));
42	    // Different secret or message -> different tag.
43	    expect(hmacSha256("s", "m")).not.toBe(hmacSha256("s2", "m"));
44	    expect(hmacSha256("s", "m")).not.toBe(hmacSha256("s", "m2"));
45	  });
46	
47	  it("timingSafeEqual matches equal strings and rejects unequal/different-length", () => {
48	    expect(timingSafeEqual("abc", "abc")).toBe(true);
49	    expect(timingSafeEqual("abc", "abd")).toBe(false);
50	    expect(timingSafeEqual("abc", "abcd")).toBe(false);
51	    expect(timingSafeEqual("", "")).toBe(true);
52	  });
53	
54	  it("AuthError carries a stable code and is an Error", () => {
55	    const err = new AuthError("bad_context", "boom");
56	    expect(err).toBeInstanceOf(Error);
57	    expect(err).toBeInstanceOf(AuthError);
58	    expect(err.code).toBe("bad_context");
59	    expect(err.name).toBe("AuthError");
60	    expect(err.message).toBe("boom");
61	  });
62	});
63
Now I have the full picture. Let me implement `verify` strictly to spec.

/home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts

− removed
export function verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult {
  // Referenced so the throwing stub still type-checks under strict settings.
  void token;
  void ctx;
  void hmacSha256;
  void base64urlDecode;
  void base64urlEncode;
  void timingSafeEqual;

  // TODO(stv): decode the three segments, validate the header, recompute the
  // canonical signing string from the payload claims and check the signature,
  // then apply the time / audience / scope / version rules and return either the
  // authenticated subject with its effective scopes or the first failing reason
  // in the precedence order documented above.
  //
  // This stub throws so the module is wired but non-functional; the behavioural
  // suite must fail until the real implementation replaces this body.
  throw new Error("verify not implemented");
}
+ added
const SKEW = 30;

/** A non-null, non-array plain object. */
function isObject(v: unknown): v is Record<string, unknown> {
  return typeof v === "object" && v !== null && !Array.isArray(v);
}

/** De-duplicate preserving first-occurrence order. */
function dedup(items: string[]): string[] {
  const seen = new Set<string>();
  const out: string[] = [];
  for (const item of items) {
    if (!seen.has(item)) {
      seen.add(item);
      out.push(item);
    }
  }
  return out;
}

/** Tokens of a space-delimited scope claim, discarding empty tokens. */
function scopeTokens(scope: unknown): string[] {
  if (typeof scope !== "string") return [];
  return scope.split(" ").filter((t) => t !== "");
}

export function verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult {
  const fail = (reason: VerifyResult extends { valid: false } ? never : Parameters<never>) => reason;
  void fail;

  // --- malformed: structure ------------------------------------------------
  const parts = token.split(".");
  if (parts.length !== 3) return { valid: false, reason: "malformed" };
  const [headerSeg, payloadSeg, sig] = parts;

  // Every segment must be valid base64url.
  let headerBytes: Uint8Array;
  let payloadBytes: Uint8Array;
  try {
    headerBytes = base64urlDecode(headerSeg);
    payloadBytes = base64urlDecode(payloadSeg);
    base64urlDecode(sig);
  } catch {
    return { valid: false, reason: "malformed" };
  }

  // Header / payload must be JSON of the expected shape (an object).
  let header: unknown;
  let payload: unknown;
  try {
    header = JSON.parse(Buffer.from(headerBytes).toString("utf8"));
    payload = JSON.parse(Buffer.from(payloadBytes).toString("utf8"));
  } catch {
    return { valid: false, reason: "malformed" };
  }
  if (!isObject(header) || !isObject(payload)) {
    return { valid: false, reason: "malformed" };
  }

  // Algorithm.
  if (header.alg !== "HS256") return { valid: false, reason: "malformed" };

  // Key selection by kid.
  const kid = header.kid;
  const secret =
    typeof kid === "string" || typeof kid === "number"
      ? ctx.keys[kid as string]
      : undefined;
  if (typeof secret !== "string") return { valid: false, reason: "malformed" };

  // Required claims must be present (key exists).
  for (const claim of ["sub", "iat", "exp", "nbf", "aud", "ver"] as const) {
    if (!Object.hasOwn(payload, claim)) {
      return { valid: false, reason: "malformed" };
    }
  }

  // --- bad_signature -------------------------------------------------------
  const canonical = Object.keys(payload)
    .sort()
    .map((key) => `${key}=${JSON.stringify(payload[key])}`)
    .join("&");
  const expected = hmacSha256(secret, canonical);
  if (!timingSafeEqual(expected, sig)) {
    return { valid: false, reason: "bad_signature" };
  }

  const p = payload as {
    sub: string;
    iat: number;
    exp: number;
    nbf: number;
    aud: unknown;
    scope?: unknown;
    scopes?: unknown;
    ver: number;
  };

  // --- expired -------------------------------------------------------------
  // Lifetime bound takes no leeway.
  if (!(ctx.now <= p.iat + p.exp)) {
    return { valid: false, reason: "expired" };
  }

  // --- not_yet_valid -------------------------------------------------------
  if (!(ctx.now >= p.nbf - SKEW)) {
    return { valid: false, reason: "not_yet_valid" };
  }

  // --- wrong_audience ------------------------------------------------------
  const aud = p.aud;
  const audienceOk =
    Array.isArray(aud) &&
    aud.some((entry) => typeof entry === "string" && ctx.audience.startsWith(entry));
  if (!audienceOk) {
    return { valid: false, reason: "wrong_audience" };
  }

  // --- revoked -------------------------------------------------------------
  // `ver` must satisfy `ver >= minVer`; a `ver` of 0 is never accepted.
  if (p.ver === 0 || !(p.ver >= ctx.minVer)) {
    return { valid: false, reason: "revoked" };
  }

  // --- effective scopes ----------------------------------------------------
  const hasScope = Object.hasOwn(payload, "scope");
  const hasScopes = Object.hasOwn(payload, "scopes");
  const scopesArray = Array.isArray(p.scopes)
    ? (p.scopes.filter((s) => typeof s === "string") as string[])
    : [];
  let effective: string[];
  if (hasScope && hasScopes) {
    const set = new Set(scopesArray);
    effective = dedup(scopeTokens(p.scope).filter((t) => set.has(t)));
  } else if (hasScope) {
    effective = dedup(scopeTokens(p.scope));
  } else if (hasScopes) {
    effective = dedup(scopesArray);
  } else {
    effective = [];
  }

  // --- insufficient_scope --------------------------------------------------
  if (ctx.requiredScopes && ctx.requiredScopes.length > 0) {
    const have = new Set(effective);
    for (const req of ctx.requiredScopes) {
      if (!have.has(req)) {
        return { valid: false, reason: "insufficient_scope" };
      }
    }
  }

  return { valid: true, sub: p.sub, scopes: effective };
}

contents
The file /home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context , no need to Read it back)
I left a stray, malformed helper. Let me remove it.

/home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts

− removed
export function verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult {
  const fail = (reason: VerifyResult extends { valid: false } ? never : Parameters<never>) => reason;
  void fail;

  // --- malformed: structure ------------------------------------------------
+ added
export function verify(token: string, ctx: VerifyContext): VerifyResult {
  // --- malformed: structure ------------------------------------------------

contents
The file /home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context , no need to Read it back)

/home/user/app/tsconfig.json

contents
1	{
2	  "compilerOptions": {
3	    "target": "ES2022",
4	    "module": "ESNext",
5	    "moduleResolution": "Bundler",
6	    "lib": ["ES2022"],
7	    "types": ["node"],
8	    "rootDir": ".",
9	    "outDir": "dist",
10	    "strict": true,
11	    "noUnusedLocals": true,
12	    "noUnusedParameters": true,
13	    "noImplicitReturns": true,
14	    "noFallthroughCasesInSwitch": true,
15	    "exactOptionalPropertyTypes": false,
16	    "esModuleInterop": true,
17	    "forceConsistentCasingInFileNames": true,
18	    "resolveJsonModule": true,
19	    "skipLibCheck": true,
20	    "verbatimModuleSyntax": false
21	  },
22	  "include": ["src", "test"],
23	  "exclude": ["node_modules", "dist"]
24	}
25
`noUnusedLocals` is on and I no longer use `base64urlEncode`. Let me drop it from the import.

/home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts

− removed
import { hmacSha256, base64urlDecode, base64urlEncode, timingSafeEqual } from "./crypto.js";
+ added
import { hmacSha256, base64urlDecode, timingSafeEqual } from "./crypto.js";

contents
The file /home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context , no need to Read it back)
shell
npm run typecheck 2>&1 && echo "=== TEST ===" && npm test 2>&1 | tail -30
output
> session-token-verify@0.1.0 typecheck
> tsc -p tsconfig.json --noEmit

=== TEST ===

> session-token-verify@0.1.0 test
> vitest run


 RUN  v1.6.0 /home/user/app

 ✓ test/smoke.test.ts  (5 tests) 6ms

 Test Files  1 passed (1)
      Tests  5 passed (5)
   Start at  19:41:17
   Duration  328ms (transform 72ms, setup 0ms, collect 58ms, tests 6ms, environment 0ms, prepare 119ms)
Typecheck is clean and smoke tests pass. Let me sanity-check my implementation against the spec's worked example and key behaviors with a throwaway script.
shell
cat > /tmp/chk.mjs <<'EOF'
import { createHmac } from "node:crypto";
import { verify } from "./src/auth/verify.ts";

const b64 = (o) => Buffer.from(JSON.stringify(o)).toString("base64url");
const sign = (secret, canonical) => createHmac("sha256", Buffer.from(secret,"utf8")).update(Buffer.from(canonical,"utf8")).digest("base64url");
const canon = (p) => Object.keys(p).sort().map(k=>`${k}=${JSON.stringify(p[k])}`).join("&");
function tok(payload, {secret="s", kid="k", alg="HS256", sig}={}) {
  const h = b64({alg,kid});
  const p = b64(payload);
  const s = sig ?? sign(secret, canon(payload));
  return `${h}.${p}.${s}`;
}
const baseKeys = { keys: {k:"s"}, now: 2000, audience:"svc.api.users", minVer:1 };

// spec canonical example
console.log("canon:", canon({sub:"u1",iat:1000,exp:3600,aud:["a"]}));

// happy path
const p1 = {sub:"u1",iat:1000,exp:3600,nbf:1000,aud:["svc.api"],ver:2,scope:"a b c",scopes:["b","c","d"]};
console.log("happy:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok(p1), baseKeys)));

// expired: now > iat+exp
console.log("expired:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok(p1), {...baseKeys, now:5000})));
// not_yet_valid
console.log("nyv:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok({...p1,nbf:5000}), baseKeys)));
// wrong audience
console.log("wrongaud:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok({...p1,aud:["other"]}), baseKeys)));
// revoked ver=0
console.log("ver0:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok({...p1,ver:0}), {...baseKeys,minVer:0})));
// insufficient scope
console.log("insuf:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok(p1), {...baseKeys, requiredScopes:["z"]})));
// bad sig
console.log("badsig:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok(p1,{sig:"AAAA"}), baseKeys)));
// malformed: 2 segments
console.log("seg2:", JSON.stringify(verify("a.b", baseKeys)));
// malformed: bad alg
console.log("alg:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok(p1,{alg:"none"}), baseKeys)));
// malformed: unknown kid
console.log("kid:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok(p1,{kid:"x"}), baseKeys)));
// malformed missing sub
const {sub, ...nosub} = p1;
console.log("nosub:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok(nosub), baseKeys)));
// scope only empty -> empty
console.log("emptyscope:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok({...p1,scope:"",scopes:undefined}), baseKeys)));
// only scope present
const onlyScope = {sub:"u1",iat:1000,exp:3600,nbf:1000,aud:["svc"],ver:2,scope:"a a b"};
console.log("onlyscope:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok(onlyScope), {...baseKeys,audience:"svc"})));
// audience prefix
console.log("prefix:", JSON.stringify(verify(tok({...p1,aud:["svc.api.us"]}), baseKeys)));
EOF
npx tsx /tmp/chk.mjs 2>&1 || node --experimental-strip-types /tmp/chk.mjs 2>&1
output
Exit code 9
npm WARN exec The following package was not found and will be installed: tsx@4.22.4

node:internal/process/esm_loader:40
      internalBinding('errors').triggerUncaughtException(
                                ^
Error [ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND]: Cannot find module '/tmp/src/auth/verify.ts' imported from /tmp/chk.mjs
Did you mean to import ../../home/user/app/src/auth/verify.ts?
    at new NodeError (node:internal/errors:406:5)
    at finalizeResolution (node:internal/modules/esm/resolve:233:11)
    at moduleResolve (node:internal/modules/esm/resolve:845:10)
    at defaultResolve (node:internal/modules/esm/resolve:1043:11)
    at nextResolve (node:internal/modules/esm/hooks:833:28)
    at resolveBase (file:///home/user/.npm/_npx/fd45a72a545557e9/node_modules/tsx/dist/register-CqMfTiWi.mjs:2:8141)
    at resolveDirectory (file:///home/user/.npm/_npx/fd45a72a545557e9/node_modules/tsx/dist/register-CqMfTiWi.mjs:2:9227)
    at resolveTsPaths (file:///home/user/.npm/_npx/fd45a72a545557e9/node_modules/tsx/dist/register-CqMfTiWi.mjs:2:10757)
    at resolve2 (file:///home/user/.npm/_npx/fd45a72a545557e9/node_modules/tsx/dist/register-CqMfTiWi.mjs:2:11938)
    at nextResolve (node:internal/modules/esm/hooks:833:28) {
  url: 'file:///tmp/src/auth/verify.ts',
  code: 'ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND'
}

Node.js v20.9.0
node: bad option: --experimental-strip-types
Path issue , let me put the script in the app dir.
shell
cp /tmp/chk.mjs /home/user/app/chk.mjs && npx tsx chk.mjs 2>&1; rm -f /home/user/app/chk.mjs
output
canon: aud=["a"]&exp=3600&iat=1000&sub="u1"
happy: {"valid":true,"sub":"u1","scopes":["b","c"]}
expired: {"valid":false,"reason":"expired"}
nyv: {"valid":false,"reason":"not_yet_valid"}
wrongaud: {"valid":false,"reason":"wrong_audience"}
ver0: {"valid":false,"reason":"revoked"}
insuf: {"valid":false,"reason":"insufficient_scope"}
badsig: {"valid":false,"reason":"bad_signature"}
seg2: {"valid":false,"reason":"malformed"}
alg: {"valid":false,"reason":"malformed"}
kid: {"valid":false,"reason":"malformed"}
nosub: {"valid":false,"reason":"malformed"}
emptyscope: {"valid":false,"reason":"bad_signature"}
onlyscope: {"valid":true,"sub":"u1","scopes":["a","b"]}
prefix: {"valid":true,"sub":"u1","scopes":["b","c"]}
All behaviors match the spec exactly , including the canonical string (`aud=["a"]&exp=3600&iat=1000&sub="u1"`), intersection-with-dedup scopes, audience prefix matching, the `ver=0` revocation, and the full reason precedence. (The `emptyscope` line is just a quirk of my test harness signing a payload with an `undefined` value that `JSON.stringify` drops , not a real case.) The implementation is complete: - **Structure/malformed**: exactly three segments, each a valid base64url (via the provided strict decoder), header & payload must be JSON objects, `alg === "HS256"`, `kid` must resolve to a secret in `ctx.keys`, and `sub/iat/exp/nbf/aud/ver` must all be present. - **Signature**: rebuilds the canonical `key=JSON.stringify(value)` string over sorted payload keys, HMACs it, and compares constant-time against the `sig` segment. - **Time**: `now <= iat + exp` (no leeway) for expiry; `now >= nbf - 30` for not-before. - **Audience**: some `aud` entry is a case-sensitive prefix of `ctx.audience`. - **Version**: `ver >= minVer` and `ver !== 0`. - **Scopes**: intersection of `scope` (split on spaces, empties dropped) and `scopes` when both present, otherwise whichever is present, else empty , de-duplicated preserving order; `requiredScopes` enforced. - **Precedence**: `malformed > bad_signature > expired > not_yet_valid > wrong_audience > revoked > insufficient_scope`. `npm run typecheck` is clean and `npm test` passes. Only `src/auth/verify.ts` was modified (plus dropping the now-unused `base64urlEncode` import there).
Final diff , what the agent changed

No file changes, the agent left the workspace untouched.

Verifier output , the proof behind the reward
tests/test.sh
VERIFIER: injecting hidden tests from /home/user/tests/hidden -> /home/user/app/test
VERIFIER: test files now present:
_oracle.ts
fuzz.test.ts
verify.test.ts
VERIFIER: typecheck
=== running hidden test suite in /home/user/app ===
=== vitest exit status: 0 ===
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: audience prefix match (case-sensitive) > no aud entry matches -> wrong audience
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > intersection when both scope and scopes are present
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > uses scope alone when only scope is present
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > uses scopes alone when only scopes is present
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > empty effective scopes when neither present
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > disjoint scope/scopes yield an empty intersection
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > required scope present in the intersection -> valid
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > required scope only in the union (not intersection) -> insufficient
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > multiple required scopes all present -> valid
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: effective scopes > empty requiredScopes demands nothing
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: version / revocation > ver equal to minVer is valid
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: version / revocation > ver below minVer is revoked
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: version / revocation > ver === 0 is always revoked, even when minVer is 0
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: version / revocation > ver above minVer is valid
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > rejects a token without exactly three segments
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > rejects a segment that is not valid base64url
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > rejects non-JSON header/payload
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > missing ver is malformed (not treated as valid or revoked)
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > missing sub / iat / exp / nbf / aud are each malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > malformed structure and missing claims > unknown kid is malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: algorithm restriction > alg 'none' is malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: algorithm restriction > alg 'RS256' is malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > deviation: algorithm restriction > alg 'HS512' is malformed
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > malformed beats everything (bad alg + bad sig + expired)
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > bad_signature beats expired/audience/version/scope
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > expired beats not_yet_valid/audience/version/scope (correct signature)
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > not_yet_valid beats wrong_audience/version/scope
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > wrong_audience beats revoked and insufficient_scope
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > revoked beats insufficient_scope
 ✓ test/verify.test.ts > failure precedence (fixed order, not check order) > insufficient_scope is the last resort when all else passes
 ✓ test/fuzz.test.ts > differential fuzz vs independent oracle > verifier result equals oracle over many random well-structured tokens
 ✓ test/fuzz.test.ts > differential fuzz vs independent oracle > agrees on raw malformed input (random byte strings and segment counts)
 ✓ test/fuzz.test.ts > differential fuzz vs independent oracle > agrees specifically on tampered-but-valid-structure tokens

 Test Files  2 passed (2)
      Tests  50 passed (50)
   Start at  19:42:31
   Duration  839ms (transform 169ms, setup 0ms, collect 225ms, tests 194ms, environment 0ms, prepare 178ms)

=== vitest exit status: 0 ===
RESULT: PASS (reward=1)

Reproduce this trial: git checkout 2f94510 && PYTHONPATH=src python3 scripts/build_site.py , then open trial/trial_71bfd72f3e024283. Re-running the agent live requires EVAL_PLATFORM_ENABLE_OAUTH_SMOKE=1 and is non-deterministic.

Trial trial_71bfd72f3e024283 · verifier authoritative; classifier explanatory.