SyncValsverifier → artifact → classifier → verdict
SyncVals · Trajectory

idempotency-middleware

claude-code claude-opus-4-8 ✗ failed GOOD_FAILURE ↑ View task
Solved from the instruction alone, tests/ and solution/ were withheld from the agent's workspace and restored only for grading.
Reward = tests/test.sh exit code (0 → resolved); the classification below is post-hoc and cannot change it.
Classification , post-hoc; cannot change the reward
GOOD_FAILUREHonest miss, the agent ran correctly but couldn't solve it. Expected for a hard task; the task is sound.
SubtypeImplementation Bugs
EvidenceTest output shows 16 identical failures: `expected undefined to be '<fence_value>'` checking `second.headers[REPLAY]`. Examples: 'expected undefined to be "5"' (line 174), 'expected undefined to be "1"' (lines 187, 197, etc.). All 51 other tests pass, including header validation, fence precedence, fingerprint canonicalization, and randomized cross-checks. The agent successfully implemented the complex Fenced Idempotency Protocol but failed to set the `Idempotency-Replay` response header when replaying cached responses.
Root causeThe agent implemented most of FIP/1 correctly but made a coding error: it failed to set the `Idempotency-Replay` response header (specified in instruction.md Section 4) when replaying cached responses. This single missing feature causes 16 test failures, while the other 51 tests pass, confirming the agent understood the protocol fundamentally.
RecommendationN/A - task is fine. The instruction clearly specifies setting the `Idempotency-Replay` header in Section 4 (Replay): "additionally set the response header `Idempotency-Replay` to the fence value of the cached attempt (a decimal string)". The agent understood this but failed to implement it correctly in the middleware code.
Trajectory
Tool-by-tool agent trajectory
23 tool calls · 4 tool types · 26 steps
Agent session started, model: claude-opus-4-8 · 30 tools available · cwd: /home/user/app

/home/user/instruction.md

contents
1	# Ticket: Implement the Fenced Idempotency Protocol for the charges API
2	
3	## Context
4	
5	`payments-api` is a small Express service (TypeScript, Node 20) exposing
6	`POST /v1/charges`. It sits behind a load balancer where clients retry
7	aggressively, and where a client may also *deliberately re-issue* an operation
8	it knows it wants to run again. A naive retry today creates a **duplicate
9	charge**.
10	
11	We are adopting a house protocol called the **Fenced Idempotency Protocol
12	(FIP/1)**, specified in full below. Implement it exactly as specified.
13	
14	The project ships every supporting piece complete , an `IdempotencyStore`
15	interface with an in-memory implementation (atomic `get` / `compareAndSet` /
16	`delete`), a response-capture helper, option handling, the charges route, the
17	clock abstraction, and the app wiring. **Two files are unimplemented stubs and
18	are yours to write:**
19	
20	    src/lib/fingerprint.ts          ->  export function computeFingerprint(...)
21	    src/middleware/idempotency.ts   ->  export function idempotency(options)
22	
23	`idempotency(options)` returns an Express `RequestHandler`. Keep the public
24	exports (`idempotency`, `REPLAY_HEADER`, `computeFingerprint`). You do not need
25	to modify any other file.
26	
27	---
28	
29	## Definitions
30	
31	- **Key** , the value of the `Idempotency-Key` request header (configurable via
32	  `options.keyHeaderName`; compared case-insensitively as Express lower-cases
33	  header names). A key whose value is empty or only whitespace counts as
34	  **blank**.
35	- **Fence** , the value of the `Idempotency-Fence` request header (configurable
36	  via `options.fenceHeaderName`). A **valid fence** is a canonical, non-negative,
37	  base-10 integer: it matches `^(0|[1-9][0-9]*)$` (so `"0"`, `"1"`, `"42"` are
38	  valid; `""`, `"-1"`, `"01"`, `"007"`, `"1.0"`, `"+1"`, `"1e3"`, `"abc"` are
39	  not) and is a safe integer. The fence is a monotonic sequence number the
40	  client assigns to an operation.
41	- **Fingerprint** , a string derived from the request that binds a key to the
42	  *shape* of the request first seen under it. See **Fingerprint** below.
43	- **In scope** , a request whose method is in `options.methods` (default
44	  `POST`, `PUT`, `PATCH`, `DELETE`). Any other method is passed straight through
45	  with `next()` and must never touch the store, require headers, or be
46	  fingerprinted.
47	- **Side effect** , running the downstream handler exactly once (`next()`),
48	  which is what creates a charge.
49	- **High-water fence** , for a given key, the largest fence value ever observed
50	  under it (across every attempt, including superseded, released, and
51	  fence-rejected ones). It never decreases while a record for the key is live.
52	
53	Error responses are JSON of the form `{ "error": <code>, "message": <string> }`
54	(the provided `apiError` helper produces exactly this). Only the `error` code
55	and HTTP status are asserted; the `message` is free text.
56	
57	---
58	
59	## Behavioural contract (this is the spec)
60	
61	Process an **in-scope** request in this order. The first matching rule wins.
62	
63	### 1. Header validation (in this order)
64	
65	1. If the **key** is missing or blank → respond **`400`** with error
66	   `idempotency_key_required`. Do not run the handler.
67	2. Otherwise, if the **fence** is missing or not a valid fence → respond
68	   **`428`** with error `idempotency_fence_required`. Do not run the handler.
69	
70	(Key is validated before fence.)
71	
72	### 2. Look up the live record for the key
73	
74	A record's lifetime is fixed when its fence is **acquired**: it **expires**
75	`options.ttlMs` after the moment of acquisition (using `options.clock.now()`),
76	and settling the attempt (completing or releasing it) does **not** change that
77	expiry. A request whose record has expired is treated as if no record exists. A
78	subsequent acquire (a fresh key, a re-run after release, or a higher fence)
79	starts a new lifetime from its own acquisition time. Let `F` be this request's
80	fence.
81	
82	**If there is no live record:** acquire the key at fence `F`, run the handler
83	(one side effect), and remember the request's fingerprint. The high-water fence
84	becomes `F`. Settle when the response finishes (see **Settling**).
85	
86	**If there is a live record**, let `M` be its high-water fence and apply
87	**fence precedence first**:
88	
89	- **`F < M` (stale fence).** This is a retry of an attempt that has been
90	  superseded by a higher fence. Respond **`409`** with error
91	  `idempotency_fence_stale`, and set the response header
92	  `Idempotency-Fence-Current` to `M` (as a decimal string). Do not run the
93	  handler.
94	
95	- **`F === M` (current fence).** Compare the record's state:
96	  - If the record is **still running** (an attempt at this fence is in
97	    progress) and the request's fingerprint **matches** the running attempt →
98	    respond **`409`** with error `idempotency_in_flight`. Do not run the handler.
99	  - If the record is **still running** and the fingerprint **does not match** →
100	    respond **`409`** with error `idempotency_fingerprint_mismatch`. Do not run
101	    the handler.
102	  - If the record is **finished and cached** (a completed attempt) and the
103	    fingerprint **matches** → **replay** it (see **Replay**). Do not run the
104	    handler.
105	  - If the record is **finished and cached** and the fingerprint **does not
106	    match** → respond **`409`** with error `idempotency_fingerprint_mismatch`.
107	    Do not run the handler.
108	  - If the record was **released** (a previous attempt at this fence failed
109	    transiently , see **Settling**) → acquire the key again at fence `F`, run
110	    the handler (a new side effect), and remember the new fingerprint. The
111	    high-water fence stays `M` (`=F`).
112	
113	- **`F > M` (advancing fence).** A strictly higher fence **supersedes** whatever
114	  is currently held , *regardless* of the held record's state or fingerprint
115	  (running, completed, released; matching or not). Acquire the key at fence `F`,
116	  run the handler (a new side effect), and remember the new fingerprint. The
117	  high-water fence becomes `F`. Any attempt that was still running at the old
118	  fence is abandoned: when it finishes, its result must be **discarded** (it
119	  must not become the cached/replayable response, and it must not delete or
120	  alter the superseding attempt's record).
121	
122	### 3. Settling (after an acquired attempt's response finishes)
123	
124	When a handler you ran produces its final response, settle the record for that
125	attempt , **but only if your attempt still owns the key at its fence** (if a
126	higher fence superseded you in the meantime, discard: do nothing). Settle based
127	on the **final HTTP status code**:
128	
129	- **Exactly `503`** → **release**: the attempt is treated as transiently failed.
130	  A later request at the *same* fence may run the handler again (see the
131	  "released" case above). Releasing must **preserve the high-water fence** (a
132	  later lower fence is still stale). Do not cache a `503` for replay.
133	- **Any other status, including `500`, `502`, and `504`** → **cache** the
134	  response (status, headers, body) so a later request at the same fence with a
135	  matching fingerprint replays it.
136	- If the connection is **aborted** before the response finishes → **release**
137	  (as for `503`).
138	
139	### 4. Replay
140	
141	To replay a cached response: write its stored status code, its stored headers,
142	and its stored body verbatim, and additionally set the response header
143	`Idempotency-Replay` to the **fence value** of the cached attempt (a decimal
144	string , *not* the literal `"true"`). A freshly executed (non-replayed) response
145	must **not** carry an `Idempotency-Replay` header.
146	
147	### Invariants
148	
149	- A request that is *not in scope* is forwarded unchanged and never touches the
150	  store.
151	- The handler runs **at most once per acquired attempt**. Two identical
152	  concurrent requests with the same key **and** the same fence produce exactly
153	  one side effect; the loser gets `409 idempotency_in_flight`.
154	- Across **different fences** there is **no de-duplication**: a higher fence
155	  always re-runs the handler (new side effect), even with a byte-identical body.
156	- This protocol **never** responds `422`, and never uses the
157	  `idempotent-replayed` header. Conflicts are `409` (with the specific `error`
158	  codes above); a stale fence is `409`; a missing/invalid fence is `428`.
159	
160	---
161	
162	## Fingerprint
163	
164	`computeFingerprint({ method, path, body })` returns a **lowercase hexadecimal**
165	string. It must be deterministic and induce exactly these equivalences (two
166	requests share a fingerprint **iff** all of the following agree):
167	
168	- the **method**, upper-cased; and
169	- the **path** (`req.path`, excluding any query string); and
170	- the **body**, under this canonicalization:
171	  - **Object key order is irrelevant** (`{a:1,b:2}` ≡ `{b:2,a:1}`).
172	  - **Keys whose name begins with an underscore (`_`) are excluded entirely**,
173	    recursively, at every object depth. They are client-side annotations and do
174	    not affect the fingerprint (`{amount:5,_trace:"a"}` ≡ `{amount:5,_trace:"b"}`
175	    ≡ `{amount:5}`).
176	  - **A string that is a canonical decimal integer is treated as the equal
177	    integer.** "Canonical decimal integer" means it matches
178	    `^-?(0|[1-9][0-9]*)$` and is a safe integer (`"100"` ≡ `100`, `"-5"` ≡ `-5`,
179	    `"0"` ≡ `0`). Strings that are *not* canonical integers are left as strings
180	    and are therefore **not** equal to any number (`"007"`, `"1.0"`, `"+1"`,
181	    `" 1"`, `"01"`, `"1.5"` stay strings).
182	  - **Arrays are order-sensitive** (`[1,2,3]` ≢ `[3,2,1]`); each element is
183	    canonicalized.
184	  - `null`, booleans, and numbers are distinct from each other and from their
185	    string spellings (`null` ≢ absent ≢ `0` ≢ `""`; `true` ≢ `1` ≢ `"true"`).
186	
187	---
188	
189	## Definition of done
190	
191	- `npm run typecheck` is clean.
192	- The behaviour above is fully implemented in `src/lib/fingerprint.ts` and
193	  `src/middleware/idempotency.ts`. A hidden suite grades it against an
194	  independent reference (correctness, all edges, randomized cross-checks, and
195	  the concurrency invariants). The trivial `test/smoke.test.ts` that ships with
196	  the project is *not* the grader.
197	- No changes to the store, the route, the response-capture helper, the option
198	  resolver, the clock, or the error helper are required.
199	
200	## Running locally
201	
202	```bash
203	npm install      # already done in the provided environment
204	npm run typecheck
205	npm test         # runs the shipped smoke test only
206	```
207
shell
find src test -type f | sort && echo "---PKG---" && cat package.json
output
src/app.ts
src/lib/clock.ts
src/lib/errors.ts
src/lib/fingerprint.ts
src/middleware/config.ts
src/middleware/idempotency.ts
src/middleware/responseCapture.ts
src/routes/charges.ts
src/server.ts
src/store/memoryStore.ts
src/store/types.ts
test/smoke.test.ts
---PKG---
{
  "name": "payments-api",
  "version": "1.2.0",
  "private": true,
  "description": "Internal payments service exposing a charge-creation API with idempotent writes.",
  "type": "module",
  "engines": {
    "node": ">=20"
  },
  "scripts": {
    "build": "tsc -p tsconfig.json",
    "typecheck": "tsc -p tsconfig.json --noEmit",
    "test": "vitest run",
    "test:watch": "vitest",
    "dev": "tsx src/server.ts"
  },
  "dependencies": {
    "express": "4.19.2"
  },
  "devDependencies": {
    "@types/express": "4.17.21",
    "@types/node": "20.14.10",
    "@types/supertest": "6.0.2",
    "supertest": "7.0.0",
    "tsx": "4.16.2",
    "typescript": "5.5.3",
    "vitest": "1.6.0"
  }
}

/home/user/app/src/store/types.ts

contents
1	/**
2	 * Persistence contract for idempotency entries.
3	 *
4	 * The store is a *dumb* persistence + atomic compare-and-swap layer: it holds
5	 * opaque {@link IdempotencyEntry} records keyed by the client-supplied
6	 * idempotency key, and exposes exactly enough primitives for the middleware to
7	 * implement the protocol. The store knows nothing about fences, fingerprints,
8	 * replay, or status codes , all of that policy lives in the middleware. This
9	 * keeps the in-memory store used in tests swappable for a Redis/Postgres-backed
10	 * store in production without changing request-handling logic.
11	 *
12	 * You do NOT need to modify the store to complete the task.
13	 */
14	
15	/** A captured HTTP response, replayed verbatim on a later request. */
16	export interface StoredResponse {
17	  statusCode: number;
18	  /** Header name (lower-cased) -> value. Hop-by-hop headers are not stored. */
19	  headers: Record<string, string>;
20	  /** Raw response body as sent to the client. */
21	  body: string;
22	}
23	
24	/** Lifecycle of a single attempt held under a key. */
25	export type EntryStatus = "in_flight" | "completed" | "released";
26	
27	/**
28	 * The record stored under one idempotency key.
29	 *
30	 * The middleware owns the *meaning* of every field; the store only persists and
31	 * returns these objects verbatim. A single key holds at most one entry at a
32	 * time (a later attempt overwrites an earlier one , see {@link IdempotencyStore}).
33	 */
34	export interface IdempotencyEntry {
35	  /** The idempotency key this entry belongs to. */
36	  key: string;
37	  /** Monotonic fence token of the attempt that currently owns the key. */
38	  fence: number;
39	  /**
40	   * The highest fence value ever observed for this key, across every attempt , 
41	   * including attempts that were superseded, released, or whose fence was
42	   * rejected as stale. Never decreases while the entry is live.
43	   */
44	  maxFence: number;
45	  /** Request fingerprint of the attempt that currently owns the key. */
46	  fingerprint: string;
47	  /**
48	   * Lifecycle state the middleware assigns to this attempt. The store does not
49	   * interpret it beyond the `(fence,status)` precondition of
50	   * {@link IdempotencyStore.compareAndSet}.
51	   */
52	  status: EntryStatus;
53	  /** Present when the attempt produced a response to be replayed. */
54	  response?: StoredResponse;
55	  /** Epoch ms at which this entry was first created (initial reserve). */
56	  createdAt: number;
57	  /** Epoch ms after which this entry is considered expired and swept. */
58	  expiresAt: number;
59	}
60	
61	export interface IdempotencyStore {
62	  /**
63	   * Atomically read the live entry for `key`, or `undefined` if none exists or
64	   * the existing one has expired (`expiresAt <= now`). Expired entries are
65	   * lazily deleted on read.
66	   *
67	   * This read is consistent with {@link compareAndSet}: there is no `await`
68	   * between the read and a subsequent set within the same synchronous turn, so
69	   * a read-then-set sequence is atomic with respect to other handlers on Node's
70	   * single-threaded event loop (the contract relied on by the tests).
71	   */
72	  get(key: string, now: number): Promise<IdempotencyEntry | undefined>;
73	
74	  /**
75	   * Atomic compare-and-set. Writes `next` for `key` *iff* the entry currently
76	   * stored under `key` is referentially equivalent to `expected` (by the
77	   * `(fence,status)` pair and presence , see the in-memory implementation):
78	   *
79	   *   - `expected === undefined` succeeds only if no live entry exists.
80	   *   - otherwise it succeeds only if the live entry has the same `fence` and
81	   *     `status` as `expected`.
82	   *
83	   * Returns `true` on success (the write happened) and `false` if the
84	   * precondition failed (a concurrent attempt got there first). The store
85	   * performs no `await` between its internal read and write.
86	   */
87	  compareAndSet(
88	    key: string,
89	    expected: IdempotencyEntry | undefined,
90	    next: IdempotencyEntry,
91	    now: number,
92	  ): Promise<boolean>;
93	
94	  /** Unconditionally delete the entry for `key`. */
95	  delete(key: string): Promise<void>;
96	}
97

/home/user/app/src/store/memoryStore.ts

contents
1	import type { IdempotencyEntry, IdempotencyStore } from "./types.js";
2	
3	/**
4	 * In-memory {@link IdempotencyStore}.
5	 *
6	 * Node runs request handlers cooperatively on a single thread, so the
7	 * compare-and-set in {@link compareAndSet} is atomic as long as it performs no
8	 * `await` between reading and writing the map. This is sufficient for a
9	 * single-process deployment and for the test-suite's concurrency scenarios; a
10	 * multi-process deployment would supply a Redis-backed implementation of the
11	 * same interface.
12	 *
13	 * This store is intentionally policy-free: it does not interpret fences,
14	 * fingerprints, or status beyond what {@link compareAndSet} needs to detect a
15	 * lost race. All protocol decisions live in the middleware.
16	 */
17	export class MemoryStore implements IdempotencyStore {
18	  private readonly entries = new Map<string, IdempotencyEntry>();
19	
20	  async get(key: string, now: number): Promise<IdempotencyEntry | undefined> {
21	    const existing = this.entries.get(key);
22	    if (!existing) return undefined;
23	    if (existing.expiresAt <= now) {
24	      this.entries.delete(key);
25	      return undefined;
26	    }
27	    return clone(existing);
28	  }
29	
30	  async compareAndSet(
31	    key: string,
32	    expected: IdempotencyEntry | undefined,
33	    next: IdempotencyEntry,
34	    now: number,
35	  ): Promise<boolean> {
36	    // NOTE: no awaits between the read and the write below , keep it that way so
37	    // the check-and-set stays atomic on the single-threaded event loop.
38	    const liveRaw = this.entries.get(key);
39	    const live = liveRaw && liveRaw.expiresAt > now ? liveRaw : undefined;
40	
41	    if (expected === undefined) {
42	      if (live !== undefined) return false;
43	    } else {
44	      if (live === undefined) return false;
45	      if (live.fence !== expected.fence || live.status !== expected.status) {
46	        return false;
47	      }
48	    }
49	
50	    this.entries.set(key, clone(next));
51	    return true;
52	  }
53	
54	  async delete(key: string): Promise<void> {
55	    this.entries.delete(key);
56	  }
57	
58	  /** Test helper: number of entries currently held (live or not-yet-swept). */
59	  size(): number {
60	    return this.entries.size;
61	  }
62	}
63	
64	function clone(entry: IdempotencyEntry): IdempotencyEntry {
65	  return {
66	    ...entry,
67	    response: entry.response
68	      ? { ...entry.response, headers: { ...entry.response.headers } }
69	      : undefined,
70	  };
71	}
72

/home/user/app/src/middleware/config.ts

contents
1	import type { Clock } from "../lib/clock.js";
2	import { systemClock } from "../lib/clock.js";
3	import type { IdempotencyStore } from "../store/types.js";
4	
5	/** Tunable behaviour for {@link idempotency}. */
6	export interface IdempotencyOptions {
7	  store: IdempotencyStore;
8	  /** HTTP methods that participate in idempotency. Defaults to mutating verbs. */
9	  methods?: readonly string[];
10	  /** Lifetime of a stored entry, in milliseconds. Defaults to 24h. */
11	  ttlMs?: number;
12	  /** Header carrying the client-supplied key. Defaults to `Idempotency-Key`. */
13	  keyHeaderName?: string;
14	  /** Header carrying the client-supplied fence token. Defaults to `Idempotency-Fence`. */
15	  fenceHeaderName?: string;
16	  /** Injectable clock; defaults to the system clock. */
17	  clock?: Clock;
18	}
19	
20	export interface ResolvedIdempotencyOptions {
21	  store: IdempotencyStore;
22	  methods: ReadonlySet<string>;
23	  ttlMs: number;
24	  keyHeaderName: string;
25	  fenceHeaderName: string;
26	  clock: Clock;
27	}
28	
29	const DEFAULT_METHODS = ["POST", "PUT", "PATCH", "DELETE"] as const;
30	const DEFAULT_TTL_MS = 24 * 60 * 60 * 1000;
31	const DEFAULT_KEY_HEADER = "idempotency-key";
32	const DEFAULT_FENCE_HEADER = "idempotency-fence";
33	
34	export function resolveOptions(options: IdempotencyOptions): ResolvedIdempotencyOptions {
35	  const methods = (options.methods ?? DEFAULT_METHODS).map((m) => m.toUpperCase());
36	  return {
37	    store: options.store,
38	    methods: new Set(methods),
39	    ttlMs: options.ttlMs ?? DEFAULT_TTL_MS,
40	    keyHeaderName: (options.keyHeaderName ?? DEFAULT_KEY_HEADER).toLowerCase(),
41	    fenceHeaderName: (options.fenceHeaderName ?? DEFAULT_FENCE_HEADER).toLowerCase(),
42	    clock: options.clock ?? systemClock,
43	  };
44	}
45

/home/user/app/src/middleware/responseCapture.ts

contents
1	import type { Response } from "express";
2	import type { StoredResponse } from "../store/types.js";
3	
4	/**
5	 * Hop-by-hop and volatile headers that must NOT be captured/replayed.
6	 * (Replaying e.g. `Date` or `ETag` from an old response would be incorrect.)
7	 */
8	const NON_REPLAYABLE_HEADERS = new Set([
9	  "date",
10	  "connection",
11	  "keep-alive",
12	  "transfer-encoding",
13	  "content-length",
14	  "etag",
15	]);
16	
17	/**
18	 * Wrap an Express {@link Response} so the final status, headers, and body can be
19	 * captured for later replay, without changing how the route handler writes its
20	 * response. Call {@link ResponseCapture.snapshot} after the handler has produced
21	 * its response (i.e. on the `finish` event or after `await`-ing the handler).
22	 *
23	 * This helper is provided complete , the idempotency middleware uses it to
24	 * obtain a {@link StoredResponse}.
25	 */
26	export class ResponseCapture {
27	  private bodyChunks: Buffer[] = [];
28	  private finished = false;
29	
30	  constructor(private readonly res: Response) {
31	    const originalWrite = res.write.bind(res) as Response["write"];
32	    const originalEnd = res.end.bind(res) as Response["end"];
33	
34	    res.write = ((chunk: unknown, ...rest: unknown[]): boolean => {
35	      this.record(chunk);
36	      // @ts-expect-error - passthrough to the original signature
37	      return originalWrite(chunk, ...rest);
38	    }) as Response["write"];
39	
40	    res.end = ((chunk: unknown, ...rest: unknown[]): Response => {
41	      if (chunk) this.record(chunk);
42	      this.finished = true;
43	      // @ts-expect-error - passthrough to the original signature
44	      return originalEnd(chunk, ...rest);
45	    }) as Response["end"];
46	  }
47	
48	  private record(chunk: unknown): void {
49	    if (chunk == null) return;
50	    if (Buffer.isBuffer(chunk)) {
51	      this.bodyChunks.push(chunk);
52	    } else if (typeof chunk === "string") {
53	      this.bodyChunks.push(Buffer.from(chunk));
54	    } else {
55	      this.bodyChunks.push(Buffer.from(String(chunk)));
56	    }
57	  }
58	
59	  get isFinished(): boolean {
60	    return this.finished;
61	  }
62	
63	  /** Build a {@link StoredResponse} from what the handler has written so far. */
64	  snapshot(): StoredResponse {
65	    const headers: Record<string, string> = {};
66	    for (const [name, value] of Object.entries(this.res.getHeaders())) {
67	      const lower = name.toLowerCase();
68	      if (NON_REPLAYABLE_HEADERS.has(lower)) continue;
69	      if (value == null) continue;
70	      headers[lower] = Array.isArray(value) ? value.join(", ") : String(value);
71	    }
72	    return {
73	      statusCode: this.res.statusCode,
74	      headers,
75	      body: Buffer.concat(this.bodyChunks).toString("utf8"),
76	    };
77	  }
78	}
79

/home/user/app/src/middleware/idempotency.ts

contents
1	import type { NextFunction, Request, RequestHandler, Response } from "express";
2	import { apiError } from "../lib/errors.js";
3	import { computeFingerprint } from "../lib/fingerprint.js";
4	import type { IdempotencyOptions } from "./config.js";
5	import { resolveOptions } from "./config.js";
6	import { ResponseCapture } from "./responseCapture.js";
7	
8	/**
9	 * Response header that flags a replayed response. Its required NAME and VALUE
10	 * are specified in `instruction.md`. (The constant value below is a placeholder;
11	 * set it to the name required by the contract.)
12	 */
13	export const REPLAY_HEADER = "idempotency-replay";
14	
15	/**
16	 * Express middleware implementing the Fenced Idempotency Protocol (FIP/1).
17	 *
18	 * The full behavioural contract is specified in `instruction.md`; that document
19	 * is the spec. Implement it here.
20	 *
21	 * Use the provided helpers (`computeFingerprint`, `ResponseCapture`, `apiError`,
22	 * `resolveOptions`) and the injected `options.store`. Keep the public exports
23	 * (`idempotency`, `REPLAY_HEADER`).
24	 */
25	export function idempotency(options: IdempotencyOptions): RequestHandler {
26	  const resolved = resolveOptions(options);
27	
28	  // Referenced so a partial implementation still type-checks; use as needed.
29	  void apiError;
30	  void computeFingerprint;
31	  void ResponseCapture;
32	  void REPLAY_HEADER;
33	  void resolved;
34	
35	  return async function idempotencyMiddleware(
36	    _req: Request,
37	    _res: Response,
38	    next: NextFunction,
39	  ): Promise<void> {
40	    // TODO(idempotency): implement the FIP/1 contract documented in instruction.md.
41	    //
42	    // This stub leaves the route wired but non-functional so the behavioural
43	    // suite fails until the real protocol is implemented here.
44	    next(new Error("idempotency middleware not implemented"));
45	  };
46	}
47

/home/user/app/src/lib/fingerprint.ts

contents
1	import { createHash } from "node:crypto";
2	
3	/**
4	 * Compute the request fingerprint that binds an idempotency key to the shape of
5	 * the request that used it. The fingerprint is a lowercase hex string; its
6	 * canonicalization rules are specified in `instruction.md`. Implement them here.
7	 *
8	 * `createHash` from `node:crypto` is imported for convenience; how (and whether)
9	 * you use it is up to you, as long as the output is a lowercase hex string with
10	 * the documented equivalence behaviour.
11	 *
12	 * TODO(fingerprint): implement the canonicalization contract.
13	 */
14	export function computeFingerprint(input: {
15	  method: string;
16	  path: string;
17	  body: unknown;
18	}): string {
19	  void createHash;
20	  void input;
21	  throw new Error("computeFingerprint not implemented");
22	}
23

/home/user/app/src/lib/errors.ts

contents
1	/**
2	 * Problem-detail style error payloads emitted by the API.
3	 *
4	 * The shape is intentionally small and stable so clients can switch on `error`.
5	 */
6	export interface ApiErrorBody {
7	  error: string;
8	  message: string;
9	}
10	
11	export function apiError(error: string, message: string): ApiErrorBody {
12	  return { error, message };
13	}
14

/home/user/app/src/routes/charges.ts

contents
1	import type { Request, Response } from "express";
2	import { Router } from "express";
3	import { randomUUID } from "node:crypto";
4	import { apiError } from "../lib/errors.js";
5	
6	/**
7	 * A deliberately side-effectful "create charge" endpoint.
8	 *
9	 * Each successful POST mints a brand-new charge id and pushes onto an in-memory
10	 * ledger. Idempotency is what prevents a retried POST from creating duplicate
11	 * charges , without it, two identical requests would create two charges with
12	 * two different ids. The tests assert on exactly this property.
13	 */
14	
15	export interface Charge {
16	  id: string;
17	  amount: number;
18	  currency: string;
19	  description: string | null;
20	  createdAt: number;
21	}
22	
23	export class ChargeLedger {
24	  private readonly charges: Charge[] = [];
25	
26	  create(input: { amount: number; currency: string; description: string | null }): Charge {
27	    const charge: Charge = {
28	      id: `ch_${randomUUID().replace(/-/g, "").slice(0, 24)}`,
29	      amount: input.amount,
30	      currency: input.currency,
31	      description: input.description,
32	      createdAt: Date.now(),
33	    };
34	    this.charges.push(charge);
35	    return charge;
36	  }
37	
38	  count(): number {
39	    return this.charges.length;
40	  }
41	
42	  all(): readonly Charge[] {
43	    return this.charges;
44	  }
45	}
46	
47	export function createChargesRouter(ledger: ChargeLedger): Router {
48	  const router = Router();
49	
50	  router.post("/", (req: Request, res: Response) => {
51	    const body = (req.body ?? {}) as Record<string, unknown>;
52	    const amount = body.amount;
53	    const currency = body.currency;
54	
55	    if (typeof amount !== "number" || !Number.isInteger(amount) || amount <= 0) {
56	      res
57	        .status(400)
58	        .json(apiError("invalid_amount", "amount must be a positive integer (minor units)"));
59	      return;
60	    }
61	    if (typeof currency !== "string" || currency.length !== 3) {
62	      res
63	        .status(400)
64	        .json(apiError("invalid_currency", "currency must be a 3-letter ISO code"));
65	      return;
66	    }
67	
68	    const description =
69	      typeof body.description === "string" ? body.description : null;
70	
71	    const charge = ledger.create({ amount, currency: currency.toLowerCase(), description });
72	    res.status(201).json(charge);
73	  });
74	
75	  return router;
76	}
77

/home/user/app/src/lib/clock.ts

contents
1	/**
2	 * A monotonic-ish wall clock abstraction.
3	 *
4	 * Injecting the clock keeps TTL / expiry logic deterministic and unit-testable:
5	 * tests advance a {@link ManualClock} instead of sleeping in real time.
6	 */
7	export interface Clock {
8	  /** Current time in epoch milliseconds. */
9	  now(): number;
10	}
11	
12	export const systemClock: Clock = {
13	  now: () => Date.now(),
14	};
15	
16	/** A controllable clock for tests. */
17	export class ManualClock implements Clock {
18	  constructor(private current = 0) {}
19	
20	  now(): number {
21	    return this.current;
22	  }
23	
24	  /** Advance the clock by `ms` milliseconds. */
25	  advance(ms: number): void {
26	    this.current += ms;
27	  }
28	
29	  /** Set the clock to an absolute epoch-ms value. */
30	  set(ms: number): void {
31	    this.current = ms;
32	  }
33	}
34

/home/user/app/src/app.ts

contents
1	import type { Express, NextFunction, Request, Response } from "express";
2	import express from "express";
3	import type { Clock } from "./lib/clock.js";
4	import { systemClock } from "./lib/clock.js";
5	import { apiError } from "./lib/errors.js";
6	import { idempotency } from "./middleware/idempotency.js";
7	import { ChargeLedger, createChargesRouter } from "./routes/charges.js";
8	import { MemoryStore } from "./store/memoryStore.js";
9	import type { IdempotencyStore } from "./store/types.js";
10	
11	export interface AppDeps {
12	  store?: IdempotencyStore;
13	  ledger?: ChargeLedger;
14	  clock?: Clock;
15	  ttlMs?: number;
16	}
17	
18	export interface BuiltApp {
19	  app: Express;
20	  store: IdempotencyStore;
21	  ledger: ChargeLedger;
22	}
23	
24	/**
25	 * Build the payments API. The idempotency middleware is mounted in front of the
26	 * mutating `/v1/charges` routes; read-only routes are not affected.
27	 */
28	export function buildApp(deps: AppDeps = {}): BuiltApp {
29	  const store = deps.store ?? new MemoryStore();
30	  const ledger = deps.ledger ?? new ChargeLedger();
31	  const clock = deps.clock ?? systemClock;
32	
33	  const app = express();
34	  app.use(express.json());
35	
36	  app.get("/health", (_req: Request, res: Response) => {
37	    res.status(200).json({ status: "ok", charges: ledger.count() });
38	  });
39	
40	  app.use(
41	    "/v1/charges",
42	    idempotency({ store, clock, ttlMs: deps.ttlMs }),
43	    createChargesRouter(ledger),
44	  );
45	
46	  // Centralised error handler so a thrown handler / failed reservation surfaces
47	  // as a clean 500 rather than a hung socket.
48	  app.use((err: unknown, _req: Request, res: Response, _next: NextFunction) => {
49	    if (res.headersSent) return;
50	    const message = err instanceof Error ? err.message : "unexpected error";
51	    res.status(500).json(apiError("internal_error", message));
52	  });
53	
54	  return { app, store, ledger };
55	}
56

/home/user/app/test/smoke.test.ts

contents
1	import request from "supertest";
2	import { describe, expect, it } from "vitest";
3	import { buildApp } from "../src/app.js";
4	import { REPLAY_HEADER } from "../src/middleware/idempotency.js";
5	
6	/**
7	 * Trivial smoke test that ships with the project. It only checks that the app
8	 * boots and the (idempotency-free) health endpoint responds. The real
9	 * behavioural grading lives in a separate, hidden suite. Implement the protocol
10	 * described in instruction.md and src/middleware/idempotency.ts.
11	 */
12	describe("payments-api smoke", () => {
13	  it("boots and serves /health", async () => {
14	    const { app } = buildApp();
15	    const res = await request(app).get("/health");
16	    expect(res.status).toBe(200);
17	    expect(res.body.status).toBe("ok");
18	  });
19	
20	  it("exposes the replay header constant", () => {
21	    expect(typeof REPLAY_HEADER).toBe("string");
22	    expect(REPLAY_HEADER.length).toBeGreaterThan(0);
23	  });
24	});
25
Now I have a complete picture. Let me implement the two files.
write · /home/user/app/src/lib/fingerprint.ts
import { createHash } from "node:crypto";

/**
 * Compute the request fingerprint that binds an idempotency key to the shape of
 * the request that used it. The fingerprint is a lowercase hex string; its
 * canonicalization rules are specified in `instruction.md`.
 *
 * Two requests share a fingerprint iff their (upper-cased) method, their path,
 * and their canonicalized body all agree. The canonicalization:
 *
 *  - object key order is irrelevant (keys are sorted);
 *  - keys whose name begins with `_` are dropped recursively;
 *  - a string that is a canonical decimal integer (`^-?(0|[1-9][0-9]*)$` and a
 *    safe integer) is treated as the equal integer;
 *  - arrays are order-sensitive; each element is canonicalized;
 *  - null, booleans, and numbers stay distinct from each other and from their
 *    string spellings.
 */
export function computeFingerprint(input: {
  method: string;
  path: string;
  body: unknown;
}): string {
  const canonical = JSON.stringify([
    String(input.method).toUpperCase(),
    String(input.path),
    canon(input.body),
  ]);
  return createHash("sha256").update(canonical, "utf8").digest("hex");
}

/** Matches a canonical, sign-optional, base-10 integer with no leading zeros. */
const CANONICAL_INT = /^-?(0|[1-9][0-9]*)$/;

/**
 * Convert a value into a deterministic, type-tagged representation. Each node is
 * a `[tag, ...]` tuple whose tag disambiguates the JSON type so that e.g. the
 * number `1` and the string `"1"` collapse together (both integers) while the
 * boolean `true` and the string `"true"` do not.
 */
function canon(value: unknown): unknown {
  if (value === null) return ["z"];
  if (value === undefined) return ["u"];

  switch (typeof value) {
    case "boolean":
      return ["b", value];
    case "number":
      if (Number.isSafeInteger(value)) return ["i", value.toString()];
      return ["n", String(value)];
    case "string":
      if (CANONICAL_INT.test(value) && Number.isSafeInteger(Number(value))) {
        return ["i", Number(value).toString()];
      }
      return ["s", value];
    case "object": {
      if (Array.isArray(value)) {
        return ["a", value.map(canon)];
      }
      const obj = value as Record<string, unknown>;
      const keys = Object.keys(obj)
        .filter((k) => !k.startsWith("_"))
        .sort();
      return ["o", keys.map((k) => [k, canon(obj[k])])];
    }
    default:
      // Functions, symbols, bigints , not valid JSON bodies; tag distinctly.
      return ["x", String(value)];
  }
}

contents
The file /home/user/app/src/lib/fingerprint.ts has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context , no need to Read it back)
write · /home/user/app/src/middleware/idempotency.ts
import type { NextFunction, Request, RequestHandler, Response } from "express";
import { apiError } from "../lib/errors.js";
import { computeFingerprint } from "../lib/fingerprint.js";
import type { IdempotencyOptions, ResolvedIdempotencyOptions } from "./config.js";
import { resolveOptions } from "./config.js";
import { ResponseCapture } from "./responseCapture.js";
import type { IdempotencyEntry } from "../store/types.js";

/**
 * Response header set on a replayed response. Per the FIP/1 contract its value
 * is the fence of the cached attempt (a decimal string), not the literal
 * `"true"`. A freshly executed response never carries this header.
 */
export const REPLAY_HEADER = "Idempotency-Replay";

/** Response header reporting the current high-water fence on a stale rejection. */
const FENCE_CURRENT_HEADER = "Idempotency-Fence-Current";

/**
 * Express middleware implementing the Fenced Idempotency Protocol (FIP/1). See
 * `instruction.md` for the full behavioural contract.
 */
export function idempotency(options: IdempotencyOptions): RequestHandler {
  const resolved = resolveOptions(options);

  return async function idempotencyMiddleware(
    req: Request,
    res: Response,
    next: NextFunction,
  ): Promise<void> {
    // Out-of-scope methods never touch the store, headers, or fingerprinting.
    if (!resolved.methods.has(req.method.toUpperCase())) {
      next();
      return;
    }

    // --- Header validation (key before fence) -------------------------------
    const keyRaw = headerValue(req, resolved.keyHeaderName);
    if (keyRaw === undefined || keyRaw.trim() === "") {
      res
        .status(400)
        .json(apiError("idempotency_key_required", "Idempotency-Key header is required"));
      return;
    }
    const key = keyRaw;

    const fenceRaw = headerValue(req, resolved.fenceHeaderName);
    if (!isValidFence(fenceRaw)) {
      res
        .status(428)
        .json(
          apiError(
            "idempotency_fence_required",
            "a valid Idempotency-Fence header is required",
          ),
        );
      return;
    }
    const fence = Number(fenceRaw);

    const fingerprint = computeFingerprint({
      method: req.method,
      path: req.path,
      body: req.body,
    });

    await process(req, res, next, resolved, key, fence, fingerprint);
  };
}

async function process(
  req: Request,
  res: Response,
  next: NextFunction,
  resolved: ResolvedIdempotencyOptions,
  key: string,
  fence: number,
  fingerprint: string,
): Promise<void> {
  const { store, clock, ttlMs } = resolved;

  // Retry while concurrent attempts win the compare-and-set race. Each iteration
  // re-reads the live record and re-derives the decision.
  for (let attempt = 0; attempt < 1000; attempt++) {
    const now = clock.now();
    const live = await store.get(key, now);

    if (live === undefined) {
      const entry = makeEntry(key, fence, fence, fingerprint, now, ttlMs);
      if (await store.compareAndSet(key, undefined, entry, now)) {
        runHandler(res, next, resolved, entry);
        return;
      }
      continue; // lost the race; re-evaluate against the new live record.
    }

    const high = live.maxFence;

    if (fence < high) {
      res.setHeader(FENCE_CURRENT_HEADER, String(high));
      res
        .status(409)
        .json(
          apiError(
            "idempotency_fence_stale",
            "the supplied fence has been superseded by a higher fence",
          ),
        );
      return;
    }

    if (fence === high) {
      if (live.status === "in_flight") {
        if (live.fingerprint === fingerprint) {
          res
            .status(409)
            .json(
              apiError(
                "idempotency_in_flight",
                "an attempt at this fence is already in progress",
              ),
            );
        } else {
          res
            .status(409)
            .json(
              apiError(
                "idempotency_fingerprint_mismatch",
                "request payload does not match the in-flight attempt",
              ),
            );
        }
        return;
      }

      if (live.status === "completed") {
        if (live.fingerprint === fingerprint) {
          replay(res, live);
        } else {
          res
            .status(409)
            .json(
              apiError(
                "idempotency_fingerprint_mismatch",
                "request payload does not match the cached attempt",
              ),
            );
        }
        return;
      }

      // status === "released": a prior attempt at this fence failed transiently;
      // a later request at the same fence may run again. High-water stays.
      const entry = makeEntry(key, fence, high, fingerprint, now, ttlMs);
      if (await store.compareAndSet(key, live, entry, now)) {
        runHandler(res, next, resolved, entry);
        return;
      }
      continue;
    }

    // fence > high: a strictly higher fence supersedes whatever is held,
    // regardless of its state or fingerprint.
    const entry = makeEntry(key, fence, fence, fingerprint, now, ttlMs);
    if (await store.compareAndSet(key, live, entry, now)) {
      runHandler(res, next, resolved, entry);
      return;
    }
    // lost the race; re-evaluate.
  }

  // Should be unreachable; fail closed rather than run an unguarded handler.
  res
    .status(409)
    .json(apiError("idempotency_in_flight", "unable to acquire idempotency key"));
}

/**
 * Run the downstream handler exactly once for an acquired attempt, capturing the
 * response so it can be settled (cached or released) when it finishes.
 */
function runHandler(
  res: Response,
  next: NextFunction,
  resolved: ResolvedIdempotencyOptions,
  acquired: IdempotencyEntry,
): void {
  const { store, clock } = resolved;
  const capture = new ResponseCapture(res);
  let settled = false;

  const settle = (aborted: boolean): void => {
    if (settled) return;
    settled = true;

    let next: IdempotencyEntry;
    if (aborted || res.statusCode === 503) {
      // Release: transient failure. Preserve the high-water fence, cache nothing.
      next = { ...acquired, status: "released", response: undefined };
    } else {
      next = { ...acquired, status: "completed", response: capture.snapshot() };
    }

    // Settle only if our attempt still owns the key at its fence. The (fence,
    // status) precondition fails if a higher fence superseded us , discard.
    void store.compareAndSet(acquired.key, acquired, next, clock.now());
  };

  res.once("finish", () => settle(false));
  res.once("close", () => {
    if (!res.writableFinished) settle(true);
  });

  next();
}

/** Replay a cached response verbatim, tagging it with the cached attempt's fence. */
function replay(res: Response, entry: IdempotencyEntry): void {
  const stored = entry.response;
  if (!stored) {
    // Defensive: a completed entry should always carry a response.
    res.status(409).json(apiError("idempotency_in_flight", "no cached response available"));
    return;
  }

  res.status(stored.statusCode);
  for (const [name, value] of Object.entries(stored.headers)) {
    res.setHeader(name, value);
  }
  res.setHeader(REPLAY_HEADER, String(entry.fence));
  res.end(stored.body);
}

function makeEntry(
  key: string,
  fence: number,
  maxFence: number,
  fingerprint: string,
  now: number,
  ttlMs: number,
): IdempotencyEntry {
  return {
    key,
    fence,
    maxFence,
    fingerprint,
    status: "in_flight",
    createdAt: now,
    expiresAt: now + ttlMs,
  };
}

function isValidFence(value: string | undefined): boolean {
  if (value === undefined) return false;
  if (!/^(0|[1-9][0-9]*)$/.test(value)) return false;
  return Number.isSafeInteger(Number(value));
}

function headerValue(req: Request, name: string): string | undefined {
  const raw = req.headers[name];
  if (raw === undefined) return undefined;
  return Array.isArray(raw) ? raw[0] : raw;
}

contents
The file /home/user/app/src/middleware/idempotency.ts has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context , no need to Read it back)

/home/user/app/src/middleware/idempotency.ts

− removed
    let next: IdempotencyEntry;
    if (aborted || res.statusCode === 503) {
      // Release: transient failure. Preserve the high-water fence, cache nothing.
      next = { ...acquired, status: "released", response: undefined };
    } else {
      next = { ...acquired, status: "completed", response: capture.snapshot() };
    }

    // Settle only if our attempt still owns the key at its fence. The (fence,
    // status) precondition fails if a higher fence superseded us , discard.
    void store.compareAndSet(acquired.key, acquired, next, clock.now());
+ added
    let settledEntry: IdempotencyEntry;
    if (aborted || res.statusCode === 503) {
      // Release: transient failure. Preserve the high-water fence, cache nothing.
      settledEntry = { ...acquired, status: "released", response: undefined };
    } else {
      settledEntry = { ...acquired, status: "completed", response: capture.snapshot() };
    }

    // Settle only if our attempt still owns the key at its fence. The (fence,
    // status) precondition fails if a higher fence superseded us , discard.
    void store.compareAndSet(acquired.key, acquired, settledEntry, clock.now());

contents
The file /home/user/app/src/middleware/idempotency.ts has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context , no need to Read it back)
shell
npm run typecheck 2>&1 && npm test 2>&1 | tail -20
output
Exit code 2

> payments-api@1.2.0 typecheck
> tsc -p tsconfig.json --noEmit

src/middleware/idempotency.ts(72,3): error TS6133: 'req' is declared but its value is never read.

/home/user/app/src/middleware/idempotency.ts

− removed
    await process(req, res, next, resolved, key, fence, fingerprint);
  };
}

async function process(
  req: Request,
  res: Response,
+ added
    await process(res, next, resolved, key, fence, fingerprint);
  };
}

async function process(
  res: Response,

contents
The file /home/user/app/src/middleware/idempotency.ts has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context , no need to Read it back)
shell
npm run typecheck 2>&1 && npm test 2>&1 | tail -15
output
> payments-api@1.2.0 typecheck
> tsc -p tsconfig.json --noEmit


> payments-api@1.2.0 test
> vitest run


 RUN  v1.6.0 /home/user/app

 ✓ test/smoke.test.ts  (2 tests) 29ms

 Test Files  1 passed (1)
      Tests  2 passed (2)
   Start at  01:18:09
   Duration  561ms (transform 117ms, setup 0ms, collect 278ms, tests 29ms, environment 0ms, prepare 114ms)
Implementation complete. Both stub files are now implemented: **`src/lib/fingerprint.ts`** , `computeFingerprint` builds a deterministic, type-tagged canonical form of `(METHOD, path, body)` and SHA-256 hashes it to lowercase hex. The canonicalizer: - sorts object keys (order-irrelevant) and recursively drops `_`-prefixed keys; - collapses canonical decimal-integer *strings* into integers (`"100"` ≡ `100`) via `^-?(0|[1-9][0-9]*)$` + safe-integer check, while keeping non-canonical strings (`"007"`, `"1.0"`, `"+1"`) as strings; - keeps arrays order-sensitive and keeps `null`/booleans/numbers distinct from each other and from their string spellings (distinct tags `z`/`b`/`i`/`n`/`s`). **`src/middleware/idempotency.ts`** , implements FIP/1 exactly: - out-of-scope methods pass straight through, untouched; - key validation (400 `idempotency_key_required`) before fence validation (428 `idempotency_fence_required`, canonical non-negative safe integer); - a retry loop around `get`→`compareAndSet` for race safety, with fence precedence first: `F<M` → 409 `idempotency_fence_stale` + `Idempotency-Fence-Current: M`; `F===M` dispatches on state (in_flight→`idempotency_in_flight`/`idempotency_fingerprint_mismatch`, completed→replay or mismatch, released→re-acquire keeping high-water); `F>M` supersedes unconditionally; - settling on `finish`/`close`: `503` or abort → release (preserves high-water, no cache); any other status → cache. Settling uses CAS keyed on `(fence,status)`, so a superseded attempt's result is silently discarded; - replay writes stored status/headers/body verbatim and sets `Idempotency-Replay` to the cached attempt's fence (decimal string); fresh responses never carry it. `npm run typecheck` is clean and the smoke test passes.
Final diff , what the agent changed

No file changes, the agent left the workspace untouched.

Verifier output , the proof behind the reward
tests/test.sh
=== staging hidden test suite into /home/user/app/test ===
=== running hidden test suite in /home/user/app ===

 RUN  v1.6.0 /home/user/app

 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > passes non-mutating methods straight through (no key/fence needed)
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > missing key -> 400 idempotency_key_required (key checked before fence)
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > blank/whitespace key -> 400 idempotency_key_required
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > missing fence -> 428 idempotency_fence_required
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required 
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required   
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required -1
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required 1.0
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required 01
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required 007
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required +1
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required 1e3
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required abc
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required 0x1
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required 1,2
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > invalid fence %p -> 428 idempotency_fence_required 0b1
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > canonical non-negative fence %p is accepted (executes) 0
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > canonical non-negative fence %p is accepted (executes) 1
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > canonical non-negative fence %p is accepted (executes) 42
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , header requirements & scope > canonical non-negative fence %p is accepted (executes) 9007199254740991
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , basic execute / replay > first request executes and is NOT marked as a replay
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , basic execute / replay > same key+fence retry replays verbatim and sets Idempotency-Replay:<fence>
   → expected undefined to be '5' // Object.is equality
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , basic execute / replay > replay reproduces a handler-produced 4xx verbatim
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , basic execute / replay > charges API: identical retry replays the same charge id, single side effect
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , fence precedence (the core trap) > a strictly-LOWER fence after a completed attempt -> 409 idempotency_fence_stale + current header
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , fence precedence (the core trap) > a strictly-HIGHER fence with the SAME body RE-EXECUTES (does NOT replay)
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , fence precedence (the core trap) > charges: higher fence, same body => SECOND charge created (no dedup across fences)
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , fence precedence (the core trap) > a higher fence with a DIFFERENT body still re-executes (fence beats fingerprint)
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , fence precedence (the core trap) > after a higher fence supersedes, the previous (now-stale) fence replays nothing
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , fingerprint mismatch is 409 (never 422) > same fence, different body after completion -> 409 idempotency_fingerprint_mismatch
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , fingerprint mismatch is 409 (never 422) > no 422 is ever produced by the middleware for key reuse
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke fingerprint canonicalization > underscore-prefixed keys are excluded => same fingerprint => replay
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke fingerprint canonicalization > integer-as-string equals integer => same fingerprint => replay
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke fingerprint canonicalization > NON-canonical numeric strings are NOT normalized ("007" != 7) => mismatch
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke fingerprint canonicalization > key ordering is irrelevant (canonical) => replay
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke fingerprint canonicalization > array order IS significant => different fingerprint => mismatch
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke fingerprint canonicalization > path is part of the fingerprint (same key+fence, different path => mismatch)
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke 5xx policy (only 503 releases) > a handler 500 is CACHED and replayed at the same fence
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke 5xx policy (only 503 releases) > status 500 is cached (replayed, not retried)
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke 5xx policy (only 503 releases) > status 502 is cached (replayed, not retried)
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke 5xx policy (only 503 releases) > status 504 is cached (replayed, not retried)
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke 5xx policy (only 503 releases) > a handler 503 is RELEASED: a same-fence retry RE-EXECUTES
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke 5xx policy (only 503 releases) > 503 release preserves the fence high-water mark (a lower fence is still stale)
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , bespoke 5xx policy (only 503 releases) > a thrown handler (=> 500 via error handler) is CACHED, not released
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , TTL (sliding on every transition) > an expired completed entry behaves as brand-new (re-executes at any fence)
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , TTL (sliding on every transition) > within TTL the completed entry still replays
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , TTL (sliding on every transition) > a record's lifetime is measured from when its fence was ACQUIRED
   → expected undefined to be '2' // Object.is equality
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , concurrency > two concurrent same-key+fence requests: exactly one executes, other gets 409 in_flight
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , concurrency > a higher fence arriving while a lower fence is in-flight SUPERSEDES (no 409), and supersedes its result
   → expected undefined to be '2' // Object.is equality
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , added edge cases (hardening) > a higher fence supersedes a RELEASED entry and re-executes
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , added edge cases (hardening) > a non-201 success (200) is cached and replayed
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 ✓ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , added edge cases (hardening) > fingerprint: whitespace in a numeric string is NOT normalized (mismatch)
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , added edge cases (hardening) > fingerprint: underscore keys excluded recursively inside arrays (replay)
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 × test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , added edge cases (hardening) > TTL is fixed at acquire: live just before expiresAt, expired at it
   → expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality
 ✓ test/random.crosscheck.test.ts > FIP/1 , randomized cross-check vs independent oracle > agrees with the oracle over many random sequences 1532ms
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , output shape > is a lowercase hex string
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , output shape > is deterministic
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > object key order does not matter
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > underscore-prefixed keys are excluded
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > underscore exclusion is recursive (nested objects too)
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > canonical integer strings normalize to integers
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > non-canonical numeric strings are NOT normalized
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > float numbers are not equal to their non-canonical string forms
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > arrays preserve order
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > method and path participate
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > null is distinct from absent and from 0/""
 ✓ test/fingerprint.test.ts > computeFingerprint , equivalence classes match the spec > boolean is distinct from numeric/string forms

⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯ Failed Tests 16 ⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯

 FAIL  test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , basic execute / replay > same key+fence retry replays verbatim and sets Idempotency-Replay:<fence>
AssertionError: expected undefined to be '5' // Object.is equality

- Expected: 
"5"

+ Received: 
undefined

 ❯ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts:174:36
    172|     expect(second.status).toBe(201);
    173|     expect(second.body.id).toBe(first.body.id); // same captured respo…
    174|     expect(second.headers[REPLAY]).toBe("5"); // fence value, not "tru…
       |                                    ^
    175|     expect(second.headers["idempotent-replayed"]).toBeUndefined();
    176|     expect(h.executions()).toBe(1);

⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯[1/16]⎯

 FAIL  test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , basic execute / replay > replay reproduces a handler-produced 4xx verbatim
AssertionError: expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality

- Expected: 
"1"

+ Received: 
undefined

 ❯ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts:187:36
    185|     expect(second.status).toBe(422);
    186|     expect(second.body.error).toBe("domain_rejected");
    187|     expect(second.headers[REPLAY]).toBe("1");
       |                                    ^
    188|     expect(h.executions()).toBe(1);
    189|   });

⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯[2/16]⎯

 FAIL  test/idempotency.fip.test.ts > FIP/1 , basic execute / replay > charges API: identical retry replays the same charge id, single side effect
AssertionError: expected undefined to be '1' // Object.is equality

- Expected: 
"1"

+ Received: 
undefined

 ❯ test/idempotency.fip.test.ts:197:36
    195|     expect(first.status).toBe(201);
    196|     expect(second.body.id).toBe(first.body.id);
    197|     expect(second.headers[REPLAY]).toBe("1");
       |                                    ^
    198|     expect(built.ledger.count()).toBe(1);
    199|

… (truncated at 12,000 chars, full verifier log is in the trial artifacts)

Reproduce this trial: git checkout 2f94510 && PYTHONPATH=src python3 scripts/build_site.py , then open trial/trial_7a3f3af0a99a4f64. Re-running the agent live requires EVAL_PLATFORM_ENABLE_OAUTH_SMOKE=1 and is non-deterministic.

Trial trial_7a3f3af0a99a4f64 · verifier authoritative; classifier explanatory.